World Bank retaliates against Parliamentary Whistleblower

World Bank retaliates against Parliamentary Whistleblower
Showing posts with label Bank. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bank. Show all posts

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Blowing the World Bank Whistle

Blowing the World Bank Whistle is an ongoing effort which started in 2004 with a Parliamentary Commission study into a World Bank financed project in the Republic of Armenia, and it continues on to an effort to persuade the Bank’s watchdog organisation, the Department of Institutional Integrity (INT), to instigate a full investigation into the wide-ranging and high-level fraud, corruption and embezzlement, exposed by the study.

In 2004, the Commission reported the fraud, corruption and embezzlement to the World Bank Armenia Country Manager and to the Department of Institutional Integrity, but by the end of 2006, rather than the problems being resolved, the individual who managed the study found that he had become the subject of World Bank ‘Whistleblower’ reprisals.

The whistleblower then found that the Bank's own Department of Institutional Integrity often prefers to punish whistleblowers rather than to solve the problems within the Bank and despite ever-increasing commitments by the major international institutions to clamp down on corruption, it is virtually impossible to find an organisation to support a claim against the Bank.

But Washington’s most influential human rights and freedom of speech organisation, the Government Accountability Project (GAP), after carefully studying the study documents, submitted a 'Demand Letter' to the INT, in support of a claim by the Whistleblower against the Bank. Later, the British Government, which had been informed of the problems since the time of the study in 2004, formally added its support.

On the 6th September, GAP released a report of its study into the INT and highlighted four claims of corruption in World Bank projects. This claim was one of those projects, and because of the wide-ranging nature of the corruption, plus the comprehensive and compelling evidence, GAP singled it out with a special request to the INT to conduct a full investigation. Armenia’s Municipal Development Project is now featured on GAP’s website.

Just prior to the GAP report, Mr. Shapiro of the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity eventually responded to the letters from GAP, explaining that the INT has three categories for claims, ‘High’, ‘Medium’ and ‘Low’, and Armenia is ‘Medium’. Mr. Shapiro however declined to commit to when a full investigation will be carried out.

This claim has also been officially registered with the Volcker Panel, which has been studying INT operations and which released its report on the 13th September. The report does not feature any specific projects, because although according to the Volcker report, the “INT plays an important role in the Bank’s overall good governance and anti-corruption drive”, the “Purpose and Scope” of the Volcker Panel study was to “carry out a comprehensive review of the INT to assess how it can best contribute to the Bank’s poverty reduction mission and to safeguard the institution from legal, fiduciary and other risks”.

It is clear from the Purpose and Scope of the Volcker Panel study that the Bank is more concerned about its own security than about protecting the interests of those who would like a reduction in the level of corruption in World Bank projects, those generally referred to as ‘Whistleblowers’.

Prior to reading the Volcker Panel study report, it was assumed that the Armenian claim was near the bottom of the INT list for investigation, because according to INT procedures, low category claims are simply filed and receive no further attention. But the Volcker study has found that “Generally, INT has been able to investigate only high priority cases” and normally medium priority cases are NOT investigated.

So although an Armenian Parliamentary Commission has submitted comprehensive and compelling evidence to the World Bank, claiming tens of millions of dollars worth of corruption, according to Volcker, the Armenian people should not expect an INT inquiry.

In July the UK Foreign & Commonwealth Office established an ‘International Development Committee’, which invites organizations and individuals to “submit 'evidence' to ensure that assistance delivered through the World Bank is in line with the priorities and objectives of the Department for International Development (DFID)”. Details of this claim are being prepared as the basis for ‘evidence’ for the committee and that will include how the UK representation at the World Bank in Washington continually ignores letters from the British Ambassador in Armenia, in which he requests their support and information about the status of the claim.

The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund will be meeting in Washington at the end of October to present requests for continued finance to the U.S. Congress. GAP will be working with Congress to make sure it is aware of how inadequately the INT responds to claims of World Bank corruption. That will be followed by work with the U.S. Senate, which has just unanimously voted to investigate World Bank corruption.

Whilst the INT is deciding on how and when it may be able to respond to the 'Demand Letter' it received from GAP in March this year, Armenian corruption is being subjected to high-level exposure in Washington and in London; corrupt World Bank consultants continue with their corruption in Armenia; the World Bank Armenia country manager is free to orchestrate more corruption (now in Kyrgyzstan), and nine months after his departure from Armenia, the World Bank's Armenia office still awaits the arrival of its replacement country manager.

This blog covers the process from the beginning; it details the fraud and corruption, the Bank’s reprisals to the whistleblower, and continues with the ongoing action to persuade the Department of Institutional Integrity to initiate a full investigation into the matter.

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist

Armenian Parliamentary Commission (2004)


Friday, July 18, 2008

The World Bank Cleans up its Act in Armenia

Since the beginning of 2007, the Government Accountability Project (GAP) has been behind an internationally supported action in Washington to have an investigation carried out into the rampantly corrupt agenda the World Bank has been driving in Armenia since the turn of the century. The Bank’s internal watchdog body, the Department of Institutional Integrity (INT), has done all it could to avoid investigating the corruption, which GAP detailed in a ‘Demand Letter’ of March 2007, and to date the INT has refused to provide information on how it has been

handling the case. However, in March this year an INT team of investigators was in Armenia and apparently an investigation has been under way.

Today, the INT still refuses to inform GAP of how its investigation is proceeding, but on the 16th July, Aristomene Varoudakis, the World Bank’s Armenia Country Manager convened a press conference to present the newly released World Bank ‘Economic Monitoring Note’, which looks at Armenia’s economic situation in the first 5 months of 2008. Information provided in the document gives cause to believe that the unrelenting pressure GAP has been putting on the Bank for the past eighteen months may have led to significant improvements in the way the Bank is now operating in Armenia.

The Blowing the World Bank Whistle blog has provided regular updates on the action
since July 2007, and on the 26th March this year, Taming Armenia’s World Bank Beast explained how The ‘Caucuses Tiger’ was soon to have its teeth pulled out and thorns stuck in its paws - by the very people who bottle fed it from birth.

A news release on the World Bank website gives an introduction into the ‘Economic Monitoring Note’, and includes: “In the first 5 months of 2008 GDP continued to grow at a strong, although slower pace compared to 2007 as a whole. At the same time, inflation accelerated.

Macroeconomic risks have intensified due to several factors, including negative changes in terms of trade driven by high international energy and food prices, less favourable international financial markets, further concentration of growth in non-tradable sectors, continuing contraction in exports, and pervasive price rigidities in product markets”

Among a list of important revelations, the Economic Monitoring Note provides details of how, since the beginning of 2006, the Government has been using one of Armenia’s major assets to pay for gas, in order to promote privatized gasification throughout the Republic and to benefit state crony profit-making domestic heating businesses - again to the detriment of the Republic and at the cost of Armenia’s under-privileged.

The report can be downloaded in English and Armenian from The World Bank Website




Saturday, May 17, 2008

ODA Loan to the Republic of Armenia

Supporting Construction of Electricity Transmission and Distribution Network

OECF (The Overseas Economic Corporation Fund, Japan: President, Chairman of the Board: Mr. Kyosuke Shinozawa) has decided to provide a loan of up to 5,399 million yen ($45 million) to fund "Electricity Transmission and Distribution Project" in the Republic of Armenia, and signed the loan agreement on February 18, 1999.

The loan agreement was signed at OECF head office in Tokyo by Mr. Shinozawa, President, Chairman of the Board, OECF and H.E. Mr. Merujan Michaellian, Minister of Energy.

Objectives and Outline of the Project

By constructing a power transmission and distribution network covering the entire national territory of Armenia (upgrading of substations and load-dispatching offices, improvement of communication equipment and rehabilitation of transmission and distribution network) as well as the installation of consumption meters, this project will improve the stability and reliability of power supply. Moreover, by aiming to reduce power transmission losses and increase the power charges collection rate, the project aims to strengthen the management foundation of the power transmission and distribution companies and improve Armenia's balance of international payments by more efficient use of energy resources.

The proceeds of the loan will be used for civil works, procurement of required electricity transmission equipment and consulting services (construction supervision, etc.).

This is a co-financing project with the World Bank.

Armenia Gives a Hundred Million Dollars to Russian Companies

Since the turn of the century, President Kocharian’s administration has ‘Privatized’ most of Armenia’s billions of dollars worth of state assets, much of it transferred to Russian companies using deceitful finance mechanisms. The ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ campaign has exposed that agenda and how the World Bank, the IMF and the Armenian authorities have fabricated an economic boom and covered up the alarming increase in corruption that has led to Armenia’s present crisis.

Now Armenia’s recently self appointed President Sargsyan is donating hundreds of millions of dollars to those private Russian companies to help their owners make even greater profits – again at the expense of the Armenian people.

On the 16th May the Armenia Liberty news reported that Tigran Davtian, Armenia’s newly appointed Minister of Finance, signed an agreement under which Germany will provide Armenia with another 74 million Euros ($117 million) in fresh low-interest loans designed to improve energy and water infrastructure and financial services. Davtian explained that the bulk of the sum (64 million Euros) will be spent on upgrading Armenia’s largest hydro-electric plant and building two high-voltage power transmission lines in the country’s northern regions.

Armenia’s largest hydro-electric plant is Gurmush, one of the five Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro Cascade Power Plants (HPP’s). In 2003 the entire Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro Cascade system was valued at over one hundred million dollars but was ‘Privatized by Russian Companies’ at the giveaway price of twenty-five million dollars. In 2004, Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission studied the Privatization and found that the package included a fifteen billion Drams ($29 million) cash donation from the Armenian Government and a 15 million dollar loan from Kfw. The result was that the Armenian people paid several million dollars for the honor of having that particular state asset privatized.

Armenia’s power transmission system was privatized in 2002 by Midland Resources Holding Ltd (MRH), this time at a giveaway price of $37 million, after the Government had spent a $40 million World Bank credit to prepare for the privatization, plus a further $45 million from Japan’s Overseas Economic Corporation Fund. That state asset privatization gambit cost the Armenian people more than fifty million dollars.

MRH stems from Moscow, with offices in Canada, so it was not surprising when in December 2004 the Armenian News Network / Groong reported that the company was transferred to Russia's power grid monopoly company Unified Energy System, better known as ‘RAO UES’

Today, the people of Armenia will be pleased to hear that, after having paid tens of millions of dollars to be relieved of the burden of their strategically vital and most profitable energy sector assets, the Government has now taken on a new Kfw loan to donate to the Russian owners so that they can make more profit from their companies. And Minister Davtian has signed a sovereign guarantee on behalf of the Government, committing the people of Armenia to repaying the more than one hundred million dollar credit.

Sunday, April 13, 2008

Armenia’s Disgrace goes to the U.S. Congress

So here we are, after a year of asking, beseeching, shouting, petitioning and screaming for a World Bank INT investigation into the corruption that has led Armenia to its recent crisis. On Thursday 17th April, the whole affair is going before a U.S. Congressional hearing, held by the U.S. Helsinki Commission, otherwise known as the Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe, or OSCE.

The hearing will focus on the ramifications of recent developments for Armenia and the United States, especially the ongoing negotiations on Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia s qualifications for assistance from the Millennium Challenge Account. Testifying before the Commission will be: Mr. Matthew Bryza, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs, Mr. Vigen Sargsian, Assistant to the President of the Republic of Armenia, and Mr. Arman Grigorian, Spokesman for Levon Ter-Petrossian, Armenia’s former President who continues to contest the recent Presidential election farce.

The Blowing the World Bank Whistle campaign has long argued that World Bank / IMF irresponsibility has led to the crisis now unfolding in Armenia. Since the turn of the century, the World’s two most prestigious sister financial institutions have been jointly nurturing a politically motivated agenda to prepare for resolution of the Karabakh conflict. The conflict of course had to be resolved; but the secretive way in which they have chosen to tackle the problem has led to a major crisis for Armenia, which in turn has led to the U.S. Congress hearing of the 17th.

Kocharian and Sargsyan have been playing down the way their Presidential election disgrace has threatened the Millennium Challenge Account, unashamedly announcing that Russia might be allowed to make up the Two Hundred and Thirty Five Million Dollar shortfall. That they could easily do by channelling a small part of the Karabakh compensation package to a Millennium Account. And although that surrogate Millennium Account will then be used to solve their own personal challenges, rather than those of Armenia’s under-privileged, they will again argue that they have served in the people’s best interests.

In monetary terms the Karabakh compensation package is likely to be some 20 times larger than the Millennium Challenge Account. Moreover, although that compensation package will be more than adequate to finance re-location for the tens of thousands who are forced to leave Karabakh and the surrounding territories, the Kocharian / Sargsyan team will inevitably find interesting ways to add to their multi-billion dollar windfall and continue squeezing every last Dram from those who will choose to move to Yerevan.

Hopefully, on the 17th the right questions will be asked for the peoples of Armenia and Karabakh. And hopefully the U.S. Congressional hearing will be able to shed some light on what has to date been a decidedly shady operation in preparation for resolution of the Karabakh conflict. And maybe with appropriate intervention following the U.S. Congressional hearing, the people of Armenia will be able to look forward to some level of normality.

Bruce Tasker
A Year Blowing the World Bank Whistle

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Taming Armenia’s World Bank Beast

In pursuance of my year-long internationally backed campaign to persuade the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) to carry out an investigation into my claim of fraud and corruption in Armenia World Bank projects, I recently sent a message to the Bank’s Country Manager suggesting that it was not too late for his friends at the INT to come to Armenia and try to restore some level of integrity in the Bank’s Armenia operations. Amazingly, this time my call did not fall on deaf ears, I received an invitation to meet with the INT team, who had apparently sneaked into Yerevan a week earlier to carry out the long-awaited investigation. I eagerly agreed, thinking that at last the INT had seen the devastation caused by the years of World Bank irresponsibility in Armenia and had decided to intervene to regulate the situation and possibly even penalize the offenders.

But my hopes were quickly dashed by an INT senior investigator, who talked about his previous communications with me and with GAP, but who I had certainly never heard of before, let alone corresponded with. And although the INT had apparently spent the past year carrying out an initial appraisal, he had far less understanding of my claim than the thousands who have followed the action through my blog and through news reports. I understood that although my claim has been a convenient excuse for an INT trip to Yerevan that is where any association between the INT and my claim ended. In true World Bank fashion, this INT team obviously had a completely different agenda for Armenia.

There is a problem; the wild beast the Bank and its sister institution the International Monetary Fund (IMF), have been creating for Armenia since the turn of the century has not only turned on its own people, killing them for peacefully demonstrating their democratic rights, it has turned on its master, calling the U.S. President a liar and criticizing his affairs in Iraq. So the mechanism which for the past ten years has been extolling the marvelous achievements of this sorry excuse for an Armenian administration now has the task of tearing it to pieces. The ‘Caucuses Tiger’ is soon to have its teeth ripped out and thorns stuck in its feet - by the very people who bottle fed it from birth and later, in the run-up to Armenia’s recent Presidential election, taught it how to stalk and kill its prey.

For years the Bank and the IMF have been building an Armenian economic boom around remarkable levels of foreign direct investment (FDI), knowing that FDI in Armenia has been nothing more than the re-assignment of stolen state assets to oversees enterprises. The same financial institutions have turned a blind eye to money laundering, preferring to praise wonderful achievements in the construction sector; the local currency has been artificially driven to ever-increasing highs to favor monopolistic importers - at the expense of ailing domestic production, but the sister institutions have reported the Dram has strengthened in response to the economic boom. And the alarming increase in corruption which has understandably accompanied this fallacious economic boom has attracted nothing more than WB/IMF lip-service.

Today, as Armenia is moving into its meticulously prepared and nigh on irreversible WB/IMF crisis, the international community has decided that it will no longer tolerate the deceit handed to it by Armenia’s tyrants. It will not be called a liar and have its international policies criticized. So it is demonstrating its displeasure by cutting off international funding. But years of feeding the beast with poverty reduction funds which were intended for the under-privileged has enabled it to generate a self-sustaining financial capability many times more than the amount of international finance the republic receives each year. So cutting off external finance is of little significance and can easily be compensated in a number of ways, most simply by a hike in food and energy prices.

So action needs to be taken and that is why the INT investigation team has eventually arrived in Armenia. They are not here to investigate rampant fraud and corruption in World Bank Armenia projects; they are here firstly to do what they do best, to repel a comprehensively documented claim of high-level and wide-ranging World Bank corruption; and secondly to manipulate a foundation on which the Bank and the IMF will be able to report a collapsing Armenian economy, in a similar way to which since the turn of the century they have been manipulating and fabricating Armenia’s dubious economic boom. In that way, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund will be able to deal a serious blow to the beast, again at the expense of the people of Armenia, who will be forced to pay the price over the counter and who will suffer increasing oppression through many coming years.

Sunday, March 23, 2008

A World Bank Crisis for Armenia – The Intrigue

Now that the Kocharian / Sargsyan team has imposed its new Presidency in Armenia, they are ready to move to full implementation of the World Bank Crisis for Armenia Program.

The UN General Assembly has adopted an Azerbaijani motion which reaffirms territorial integrity of Azerbaijan, demands the withdrawal of all Armenian forces from the occupied territories, and refers to outrageous and massive illegal Armenian settlement in the territories. Sargsyan is already on his way to Russia and immediately after his inauguration he will be meeting with his Azerbaijani counterpart to talk about resolution of the Karabakh conflict.

Blowing the World Bank Whistle has covered how the signing of the Karabakhi agreement will initiate the re-location of settlers from the occupied territories to their recently constructed apartments in Yerevan and through acknowledgment of Karabakhi independence Armenia will be relieved of any responsibility it may have to Karabakh. The occupied territories have been held by Armenia since 1993 as a security ring for the capital city Stepanakert, and with them under Azerbaijani control, Karabakh will be under increasing threat, causing its population to join the exodus.

The finance for the World Bank Armenia Crisis Program is the intriguing part of the jigsaw, a closely guarded secret. And no doubt for the people of Armenia, who will be paying for the whole sordid and highly corrupt affair, it will remain that way. But the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the Armenian tyrants who have for the past five years or more been carefully preparing for this moment, are in no doubt of where the finance is coming from; of how many billions of dollars are involved, and of how that money will be surreptitiously manoeuvred into Armenia to create another fabricated wave of foreign investment, and importantly to escape the attention of the rightful beneficiaries, the people of Armenia.

A most suiting scenario is of course through the Kocharian / Sargsyan friends in Russia, who in the run up to the recent Presidential election farce came to Armenia announcing their intention to increase investment in the Armenia construction sector. Why would Russian oligarchs want to increase their investment in Armenia’s construction sector, when projects they have purportedly already financed been stacking up for the past years and as yet have failed to find the tens of thousands of occupants needed to return the hundreds of millions of dollars investment already committed.

Blowing the World Bank Whistle has been posing that question throughout the past year, and today the answer is no longer a secret. The apartments are needed to re-house the residents who are driven from Karabakh and the surrounding territories when Sargsyan signs the agreement he has been keeping under his belt as a tool to persuade the international community the legitimacy of his recently enforced Presidency.

But Russia’s private investors will not be providing the apartments free of charge, and equally those who are forced to re-locate will not cherish the thought of losing their homes in Karabakh, or the surrounding territories, and having to pay the exorbitant prices being asked for Yerevan’s recently constructed real-estate. A compensation package must therefore be in place to finance the entire re-location program, and that compensation will undoubtedly be from the party who stands to gain most - Azerbaijan.

Azerbaijan will undoubtedly pay the multi-billion dollar cost of the program in preference to expending even more money, losing many lives and destroying valuable assets in a war to regain Karabakh sovereignty. The international community would be persuaded to support such a scenario, preferring not to unduly publicize the tens of thousands forcibly re-located; Russia would take a healthy cut for facilitating the compensation to investment conversion program, and Armenia’s state cronies will pick up their multi-billion dollar reward for the years they have been patiently laundering their money. And yet again, all at the expense of the people of Armenia, who will find themselves under years of increasing tyranny at the hands of the very people they saved from an Azerbaijani onslaught in the early 90’s.

That is why, for the past year the World Bank’s investigatory unit, the Department of Institutional Integrity, has refused to carry out an investigation into rampant fraud and corruption in World Bank Armenia projects, despite repeated requests from me and from the influential international group that supports my claim, because it knows that this World Bank Crisis Program for Armenia has been completely unscrupulous and highly corrupt.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

A World Bank Crisis for Armenia

The media has covered the Armenia crisis as it unfolded, through the recent pre-election period, on Election Day, and particularly since the subsequent bloody events of the 1st March. Irrespective of political leanings, all agree that Armenia is going through a crisis period. Through my Blowing the World Bank Whistle campaign, I have been reporting on Armenia’s crisis for more than a year, not as it unfolds, but through the latter period of its development. If not challenged, the crisis is destined to continue and worsen through many coming years.

The Kocharian / Sargsyan team now feels confident enough in their new illegally self-imposed Presidency to put the final pieces of the jigsaw into place. Parliament’s former Speaker, adorned by his recently adopted morals, has been reincarnated by Armenia’s new President Sargsyan, the very person who created him for a previous election fiasco, and together they are feverishly passing resolutions which on the one hand give Karabakh independence, whilst on the other take away any independence Armenia may have hitherto enjoyed.

In March this year, the UN General Assembly adopted an Azerbaijani motion reaffirming territorial integrity of Azerbaijan and demanding withdrawal of all Armenian forces from the occupied territories. The resolution refers to a UN fact-finding mission of 2005, which confirmed an outrageous Armenian policy of massive illegal settlement in the territories. Armenia has preferred to downplay that part of the equation, and the Minsk group, which has been coordinating conflict resolution for the past ten or more years, refers to the people located in the surrounding territories as ‘military personnel’. It is now generally understood that soon the final settlement will be signed and sealed, and that will be the starter for stage two of the World Bank’s crisis for Armenia.

In the lead up to the February election, Sargsyan and Kocharian promised to not capitulate on the Karabakh question. But on the 6th June, Sargsyan met with his Azerbaijani counterpart in St. Petersburg to talk about a final settlement, and he and Kocharian are now both expressing their eagerness to sign the conflict resolution agreement and immediately return the seven regions that make up the ‘surrounding territories’ to Azerbaijan.

When that agreement is signed, the Armenian settlers living in the occupied territories will flee their homes, many to Yerevan, where their new apartments have awaited them for the past several years, thanks to Armenia’s ever-caring authorities who have been laundering their illicit gains in Yerevan’s booming construction sector. Karabakh will not only have lost its security belt, but Armenia’s unique acknowledgment of Karabakhi independence will relieve its recently inaugurated President of any responsibility he may have had to his kinfolk. Karabakhi inhabitants will therefore join the exodus, fearful of an Azerbaijani onslaught, many to the apartments and the secure future which have long been under preparation for them in Galus Sarkissian’s Better than Heaven Armenia Yerevan. Bryza is now eventually talking about the international finances to fund this operation, which have no doubt long been agreed, and in recent months Armenia’s leaders have been putting into place the real-estate support services needed to reap the billions of dollars rewards for their years of patient money laundering.

The World Bank / International Monetary Fund crisis program for Armenia will soon be finally and successfully completed, and whilst it is difficult to imagine what may be the fate for those who remain in Karabakh, the future for the people of Armenia is inevitable - less independence, less freedom and many years of increasing oppression.

In exchange for Armenia’s agreement to capitulate on the Karabakh issue, the Bank and the IMF have been reporting an Armenian economic boom, with remarkable levels of foreign direct investment (FDI) and a thriving construction industry. But the WB/.IMF have known that FDI in Armenia has been nothing more than the re-assignment of stolen state assets to state cronies who have teamed up with oversees partners, often in Russia. The same financial institutions have also turned a blind eye to massive money laundering, preferring to praise wonderful achievements in the construction sector; the local currency has been artificially driven to ever-increasing highs to favor monopolistic importers - at the expense of ailing domestic production, but the sister institutions have reported the Dram has strengthened in response to the economic boom. And the alarming increase in corruption which has understandably accompanied this fallacious economic boom has attracted nothing more than WB/IMF lip-service.

The ‘Caucuses Tiger’ the Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have been nurturing since the turn of the century is now fully grown, and it has broken out of its cage. It has turned on its own people, killing them for peacefully demonstrating their democratic rights. Moreover, it has turned on its master, calling the U.S. President a liar and criticizing his affairs in Iraq. So the international financial institutions, which for the past ten years have been extolling the marvelous achievements of Armenia’s administration, had the task of bringing their ‘Caucuses Tiger’ back under control.

As Armenia was moving into its meticulously prepared and nigh on irreversible WB/IMF crisis, the international community decided that it would no longer tolerate the deceit handed to it by Armenia’s tyrants. It would not be called a liar and have its international policies criticized, so it demonstrated its displeasure by cutting off international funding.

But years of feeding the ‘Caucuses Tiger’ with poverty reduction funds which were intended for the under-privileged, created a situation in which Armenia’s tyrants were generating a self-sustaining financial capability many times greater than the amount of international finance the Republic receives each year. So cutting off external finance would be of little significance, and could be compensated in a number of ways, such as by hikes in food and energy prices and by resorting to costly inter-governmental credits.

The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund resolved not to investigate the cause of the crisis, the rampant corruption the WB/IMF had been driving since the turn of the century, but to tame the beast they themselves had created. The Bank sent its INT investigation team to Armenia to navigate a ‘U-Turn’ away from Armenia’s economic boom toward a similarly manipulated, but more realistic collapsing Armenian economy. This again is at the expense of the people of Armenia, who are already paying the price over the counter, who will be burdened with costly inter-governmental credits, and who will suffer many years of increasing oppression.

With the determined support of Washington’s most influential human rights and freedom of speech organization, the ‘Government Accountability Project’ (GAP), for the past year we have been pressing the INT to carry out an investigation into this politically motivated and highly corrupt agenda the World Bank has been driving in Armenia since the turn of the century, based on comprehensively documented evidence I gathered as Senior Specialist for Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission in 2004.

The Bank and its watchdog unit, the Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) have little respect for transparency, preferring to conduct their activities behind closed doors. But it now appears that the INT has eventually carried out its investigation, using my claim as pretence. The latest World Bank Armenia report clearly shows that the ‘Caucuses Tiger’ is now having its teeth extracted and thorns stuck in its feet - by the very people who bottle fed it from birth and later, in the run-up to Armenia’s recent Presidential election, taught it how to stalk and kill its prey.

The final outcome of the Karabakh part of the equation has yet to be seen. But with similar determination and ever-widening exposure, it is hoped that when the agreement is eventually signed, the people who will suffer as a result will be able to claim the compensation to which they will be entitled.

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist

Armenian Parliamentary Commission (2003/4)

Whistleblower

Thursday, March 6, 2008

Armenia – A Crisis Long in the World Bank Making

A Parliamentary Commission study into World Bank (WB) projects in 2004 amazingly found that the World Bank and its sister institution the International Monetary Fund (IMF) were clearly orchestrating ways and means to divert state assets from the Armenian public to a small circle of state associated cronies. Although the commission worked for only a year and studied a very limited sector of WB/IMF projects, it exposed fraud and embezzlement valued at more than two hundred million dollars, about a third of the state budget. Much of that was facilitated through a wider illicit program to transfer, virtually free-of-charge, billions of dollars worth of state assets to state officials, who operated through international front companies, often in Russia, and it included other methodologies which were used to siphon off hundreds of millions of dollars of poverty reduction funds to fill the coffers of the same corrupt state officials.

Fully aware of this massive theft of state assets and misappropriation of state funds, the Bank and the IMF continued to report years of economic boom, led by Foreign Direct Investment in the privatization of state assets, and followed by a boom in the construction sector. The Northern Prospect project of shops, offices and apartments is the star in the construction crown, adorned by dozens of apartment buildings. The construction epidemic has been spreading since the turn of the century, and with ever-increasing fervor; new apartment buildings occupy every available square meter of Yerevan’s city center and even sprawl throughout the outer suburbs in what appears to be a determined rush to expand the availability of real estate square meterage. But the offices and apartments continue to stand empty. Moreover, during the same period, Armenia’s population has seen a reduction of more than half a million, the lesser-privileged having been driven from their Republic to earn a living elsewhere.

In 2004, this presented a quandary to the Parliamentary Commission. Why were the corrupt state cronies continuing to pump hundreds of millions of their illicit dollars each year into construction projects, when there was no sign of the rush of eager punters they needed to turn their money laundering full circle? But by the beginning of 2007, the clouds over the internationally sponsored Yerevan horizon transformation started to clear. It became apparent to those in the know that the ground works were being laid for an eventual resolution of the Karabakh problem. The international community has long been demanding that Armenia withdraw from the occupied territories around Karabakh, as a lead-in to the full return of Karabakh to Azerbaijan. But despite ever-increasing pressure from the Minsk group, their final guidelines of 2004 continued to gather dust. In fact, the guidelines for compromise of the Karabakh issue are essentially the same as those President Kocharian used against his predecessor, Levon Ter-Petrossian in 1997, to drive him out of his Presidential office.

The preparation has been going on in secret right under every one of Yerevan’s million noses, with Kocharian determined the people of Armenia and of Karabakh should not have an inkling of his plan. So he waited his moment, the 2008 Presidential election, when he was to hand over his Presidential sword to his hand picked successor, Serge Sargsyan. With that feat behind them, and with total dominance over Armenia, Sargsyan and Kocharian could finally wash their hands of any responsibility toward their kindred folk and eventually sign the Karabakh agreement. That would lead to an immediate outflow of several thousand refugees from the surrounding territories, followed by an inevitable second wave of tens of thousands from the Karabakhi homeland, more than sufficient to fill the recently constructed Yerevan apartments.

It has been a well-conceived, well planned internationally supported program, essentially to resolve the Karabakh problem, but at the same time giving Armenia’s corrupt state cronies the opportunity to finally reap the rewards of the billions of embezzled dollars they have been laundering through the past years of construction. Azerbaijan will happily pay the two or three months worth of oil revenue needed to have Karabakh back under its control, Russia will probably act as go-between, converting the multi-billion dollar Azerbaijani compensation package to increased Russian investment in Armenia’s construction sector, and the people of Armenia will not only find themselves under increasing Karabakhi led tyranny for the next who knows how many years, they will again have the pleasure of knowing that billions of dollars of their compensation money will have been nicely siphoned off by their leaders - and all with the support and assistance of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund.

It is for this reason that, since January 2007, I have been pursuing my internationally supported ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ campaign, and why through the past year I have been articulating this message to senior representatives of the international community, including the UK Government, the Council of Europe, the OSCE, the UN, and the World Bank, for them to be assured that the people of Armenia know what the international community has been planning since the turn of the century and why Armenia is now under a state of emergency. And in as far as after a year of asking, the World Bank’s watchdog organization, the Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) obviously has no serious intention to investigate my claim of World Bank fraud and corruption in Armenia, it is for that reason I support Levon Ter-Petrossian in his fight to return independence to Armenia.

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist

Armenian Parliamentary Commission (2003/4)

Monday, February 18, 2008

World Bank Armenia Corruption Marches On with Transparency

For the past six months, whilst our international team of Governmental and Non-Governmental organizations has been pressing the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) to carry out an investigation into my claim of fraud and corruption in Armenian World Bank projects, I have attended a number of meetings with the local chapter of Transparency International (TI) and provided them with copies of many of the claim documents. TI has followed my action through the limited sector of the local media which is sufficiently independent to be able to follow the claim, plus through the international media, which has notably more freedom, and today TI has a pile of claim related articles in a portfolio some 3 of 4 inches thick.

TI is one of the Worlds foremost international organizations in the fight against corruption and their reports continually repeat the need to strengthen the effort, including with respect to combating corruption within the donor organizations. I was therefore pleased to recently receive a message from TI that their board of directors had convened and eventually agreed to formally support my action, adding that their Berlin office was preparing a letter for submission to the Bank.

Today, Google alerted me to an article in the Armenian publication ArmeniaNow, which articulated how Amalia Kostanyan, Armenia’s TI director, explained that “Armenia’s Anticorruption Struggle is a major challenge”. I read the article with eagerness, convinced that she would at last make reference to my ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ campaign, especially as the Armenia TI chapter no doubt has more information than both the Bank and its Department of Institutional Integrity put together.

But again I was to be disappointed; no mention of rampant World Bank corruption; no mention of how the Department of Institutional Integrity had been fending off an investigation for the past ten months; no mention of how the Bank’s recently appointed Country Manager had announced my claim was unfounded, despite him not having seen the documentation; and no mention of the high-level international support to the claim, which accuses the former Country Manager as a colluder in the wrongdoings - at a cost to the people of Armenia of tens of millions of dollars.

It is clear that, as with most other international organizations and institutions, such as the World Bank, the IMF, the United Nations, the OSCE, and many others, which bawl about the problems created by corruption and the need to wipe it out and to penalize the corrupt, Transparency International is fully committed to talking and writing about corruption, but when it comes to supporting an effort that exposes corruption and demands that it be investigated, Transparency International’s commitment is strictly LIMITED.

Thank you Transparency International for eventually agreeing to support my claim - But no thanks.

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

World Bank Armenia Corruption – The Politics

Through the past ten months, whilst the Government Accountability Project, the UK’s Foreign & Commonwealth Office, the British Ambassador in Armenia and I have been battering our heads against the World Bank’s institutional integrity brick wall, we have been debating why, since the turn of the century, the financial institutions have been orchestrating an escalation of Armenian corruption. The Permanent Representatives of both the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have been watching how billions of dollars worth of Armenian public assets has been stolen by a small circle of state cronies, who have concealed their involvement in the takeover process by working through a variety of overseas organizations. But the institutions have made little mention of the criminal activity, preferring to highlight how Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has been the spearhead of a remarkable economic boom. The institutions have also overseen numerous financial schemes, which each year have facilitated the embezzlement of hundreds of millions of dollars worth of public funds. But they have praised foreign investment in major construction projects, knowing that foreign investment has been virtually non-existent and the construction has simply been the laundering of those funds.

When in 2004, Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission raised the corruption problem with the World Bank Country Manager, he responded with aggression, and took steps to punish unwelcomed inquisitiveness. And when the same Parliamentary Commission presented documents to the Resident Representative of the IMF, indicating a scam of more than 100 million dollars, knowing Armenia has a ‘Technical Assistance’ agreement, under which the IMF is obliged to monitor and normalize all financial activity within the Armenian state system, the representative said that he had ‘Noticed the Problem’ and explained that his intervention to stop the scam was ‘Dependent on his Conscience’. It turned out that his conscience was not all it could have been; the scam went ahead, the Armenian people lost another valuable state asset, and the IMF joined its World Bank partner in the release of another glittering report on Armenia’s remarkable economic boom.

Why have the international financial institutions been so supportive of Armenia’s precarious economic boom and why have they been so nonchalant about the major problem of corruption, which has led to what today is already a well-entrenched Armenian autocracy? Could it have been for personal gain, or for collective gain, or in pursuit of a quick economic fix for Armenia, or could there be a more sinister reason? Information that has become available leading up to the February 19th Presidential election gives grounds to believe the reason is the latter, in support of a political agenda.

The corrupt Armenian authorities have been pumping hundreds of millions of their illicitly earned dollars into hundreds of thousands of square meters of accommodation space. But the ever-increasing newly constructed apartment buildings have now stood empty for several years. Moreover, in the past year or two, the quality of construction has deteriorated from the not unimpressive of five years ago, to the decidedly slip-shod of today. Even half-built apartment buildings which have stood like skeletons on the outskirts of Yerevan since the end of the Soviet period are now being rushed to completion, using all manner of unsightly construction materials. And through the past several months, property agencies have sprung up around Yerevan, owned by the same state cronies and their buddies, when apart from those within the inner circle, who may receive a new apartment (or three) in return for services rendered, there is simply no sign of the thirty or forty thousand punters needed to bring Yerevan’s newly constructed real estate to life.

But the people of Armenia should not dismay; their economic boomer babes have got a multi-billion dollar ace tucked so well up their sleeves, that after several years of preparation, ably assisted by their friends in the international financial institutions, only the very best informed have an inkling of the full house the new President is about to slap on his Republic of Armenia table.

Soon after Serge Sargsyan has terrorized himself into the Presidential Palace, all will eventually be revealed. The people of Armenia will see a sudden influx of a new generation of Yerevanites, who will not only move into the spanking new apartments, but who will take up their positions in the booming Armenian economy, and in the new administration. The multi-billion dollar money laundering of the past years will then bear its bountiful fruit, no doubt with more help from the international community, and the people of Armenia will understand why the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) in Washington should long ago have responded to my claim and open a full investigation into fraud and corruption in Armenia World Bank projects.

World Bank Armenia Corruption – The Politics

Through the past ten months, whilst the Government Accountability Project, the UK’s Foreign & Commonwealth Office, the British Ambassador in Armenia and I have been battering our heads against the World Bank’s institutional integrity brick wall, we have been debating why, since the turn of the century, the financial institutions have been orchestrating an escalation of Armenian corruption. The Permanent Representatives of both the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have been watching how billions of dollars worth of Armenian public assets has been stolen by a small circle of state cronies, who have concealed their involvement in the takeover process by working through a variety of overseas organizations. But the institutions have made little mention of the criminal activity, preferring to highlight how Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has been the spearhead of a remarkable economic boom. The institutions have also overseen numerous financial schemes, which each year have facilitated the embezzlement of hundreds of millions of dollars worth of public funds. But they have praised foreign investment in major construction projects, knowing that foreign investment has been virtually non-existent and the construction has simply been the laundering of those funds.

When in 2004, Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission raised the corruption problem with the World Bank Country Manager, he responded with aggression, and took steps to punish unwelcomed inquisitiveness. And when the same Parliamentary Commission presented documents to the Resident Representative of the IMF, indicating a scam of more than 100 million dollars, knowing Armenia has a ‘Technical Assistance’ agreement, under which the IMF is obliged to monitor and normalize all financial activity within the Armenian state system, the representative said that he had ‘Noticed the Problem’ and explained that his intervention to stop the scam was ‘Dependent on his Conscience’. It turned out that his conscience was not all it could have been; the scam went ahead, the Armenian people lost another valuable state asset, and the IMF joined its World Bank partner in the release of another glittering report on Armenia’s remarkable economic boom.

Why have the international financial institutions been so supportive of Armenia’s precarious economic boom and why have they been so nonchalant about the major problem of corruption, which has led to what today is already a well-entrenched Armenian autocracy? Could it have been for personal gain, or for collective gain, or in pursuit of a quick economic fix for Armenia, or could there be a more sinister reason? Information that has become available leading up to the February 19th Presidential election gives grounds to believe the reason is the latter, in support of a political agenda.

The corrupt Armenian authorities have been pumping hundreds of millions of their illicitly earned dollars into hundreds of thousands of square meters of accommodation space. But the ever-increasing newly constructed apartment buildings have now stood empty for several years. Moreover, in the past year or two, the quality of construction has deteriorated from the not unimpressive of five years ago, to the decidedly slip-shod of today. Even half-built apartment buildings which have stood like skeletons on the outskirts of Yerevan since the end of the Soviet period are now being rushed to completion, using all manner of unsightly construction materials. And through the past several months, property agencies have sprung up around Yerevan, owned by the same state cronies and their buddies, when apart from those within the inner circle, who may receive a new apartment (or three) in return for services rendered, there is simply no sign of the thirty or forty thousand punters needed to bring Yerevan’s newly constructed real estate to life.

But the people of Armenia should not dismay; their economic boomer babes have got a multi-billion dollar ace tucked so well up their sleeves, that after several years of preparation, ably assisted by their friends in the international financial institutions, only the very best informed have an inkling of the full house the new President is about to slap on his Republic of Armenia table.

Soon after Serge Sargsyan has terrorized himself into the Presidential Palace, all will eventually be revealed. The people of Armenia will see a sudden influx of a new generation of Yerevanites, who will not only move into the spanking new apartments, but who will take up their positions in the booming Armenian economy, and in the new administration. The multi-billion dollar money laundering of the past years will then bear its bountiful fruit, no doubt with more help from the international community, and the people of Armenia will understand why the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) in Washington should long ago have responded to my claim and open a full investigation into fraud and corruption in Armenia World Bank projects.

Friday, February 1, 2008

World Bank Armenia Corruption – The effects

For the past several months, ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ has been supported by the Armenian and international media in documenting how the World Bank and its sister institution, the International Monetary Fund, have absolutely no defense for how they have been driving major corruption escalation in Armenia since the turn of the century.


Representatives of the International Financial Institutions (IFI’s), who have been in Armenia for more than fifteen years, introducing and overseeing state-of-the-art governance and accountability, have been helping Government cronies cheat the people of Armenia out of hundreds of millions of dollars each year, using a wide variety of intriguing finance mechanisms. The same IFI representatives report how the Armenian economy continues to boom, when they know the Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has simply been the illegal transfer of state properties to corrupt state officials, and the construction boom, also apparently by foreign investors, is the same small circle of corrupt state cronies laundering their ill-gotten gains.


The World Bank and the IMF make little reference that through the same economic boom years, Armenian corruption has escalated out of all proportion. And that corruption has been accompanied by the inevitable evolvement of a well-entrenched autocratic authority, which has strengthened its grip in sync with the flourishing corruption. Autocracy thrives through enforced unlawfulness, in which bread winners are constantly in fear of retribution from the state, should they attempt to swim against the rushing and festering autocratic tide - especially important at election times.


State-connected oligarchs monopolize all major products and services, often in the guise of a foreign investor. Including fuels, solid and liquid food products, finance, energy, communications, transport, even the water the Armenian people drink. They prey on the domestic market, dictating prices and manipulating the value of the local currency to benefit importers, apathetic to suffering exporters, and with one objective, to make fortunes for themselves and their palls further up the pecking order.


State officials repeatedly deceive with promises of massive investments to benefit the people of Armenia, when in practice their intent is to use the resources they have extorted from the people, through a plethora of well-tested schemes, to satisfy their own insatiable gluttony.


According to them, paradise is thumping on Armenia’s door. Armenia will have a new 1,000 megawatt atom power station to eliminate the need for all fossil energy resources. But as the Minister speaks, he is squandering 150 million dollars, entrusted to him by the Armenian people to build a new gas fired power station in Yerevan, and the Hrazdan gas-fired power station, which has already soaked up as much for refurbishment, is being gifted to yet another foreign investor. Mini-hydro energy projects are springing up all around the Republic, financed by Government managed grants and credits, also monopolized by the same group of cronies. The World Bank is sponsoring a new ethanol industry, and apparently Armenia is to be the first to use the Jerusalem artichoke weed as the feedstock; and the Araks River, which runs at a snails pace along the Armenia – Iran border, is to be adorned with a massive new hydro-station. That will no doubt stand next to the impressive new 3 billion dollar oil refinery which was built at the time of last year’s Parliamentary election. Or maybe it will stand next to the new 1.7 billion dollar oil refinery which is due to be opened just after the upcoming Presidential election. And the recent Russian monopolization of Armenia’s railroad system has already given birth to a new high-speed railway line, which is expressing people and goods from Yerevan to Teheran and back.


Then, last week, Armenia saw its ever-caring President announcing the opening of yet another sugar factory – and this time he was not looking at a bottle of sugar being ceremoniously buried in a hole in the ground, he was standing next to one of two newly implanted stanchions, which are to be the new sugar factory.


Wake Up Armenia!

How many times can you be fooled by the same old stories?

They say that some of the people can be fooled all of the time, and all of the people can be fooled some of the time, but all of the people can not be fooled all of the time. But that saying apparently does not apply to the people of Armenia.


The 1,000 megawatt atomic power station is nothing but a state sponsored fairytale, together with the Araks river hydro-plant, and the Iran-Armenia railroad line, not to mention the 3 billion dollar, or the 1.7 billion dollar oil refinery. When will the Armenia people learn that, if today’s Armenian authorities do anything, they do it only for one purpose – to fill their own already overflowing pockets.


But the new sugar factory is a different story; that is reality.

But unfortunately for Armenia’s farmers, it will not be the sugar factory the President has promised - for the fourth or fifth time. The new construction in Akhurian is not to benefit the struggling farmers of the earthquake devastated Shirak and Lori Marzes. It will be a completely different animal, and as usual, it will benefit the small circle of state cronies, who now intend to tighten their monopolize over Armenia's sugar industry.


As usual, and especially in the run-up period to an election, Armenia’s authorities are busy promoting all manner of marvelous economic development initiatives for the people of Armenia, when in practice they are preparing to again strengthen their grip on the Armenian society - a grip that is already iron fast.


Why do I have an interest in what the Armenian authorities might be doing with the Armenian people? Because to an embarrassing extent it is the result of the disgraceful actions of the Armenia representatives of the international financial institutions, who have been driving Armenian corruption, and today’s Armenian dictatorship, for the past seven or eight years.


And soon, when the people of Armenia eventually find out why those very same insatiably greedy Armenian state cronies have been investing billions of their ill-gotten dollars into hundreds of thousands of square meters of accommodation space that nobody apparently needs, or wants, then they will understand why the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) in Washington should respond to my claim and open a full investigation into fraud and corruption in Armenia World Bank projects.

The World Bank’s INT Snubs Volcker

In September 2007, after a study that lasted several months, and including a highly distinguished panel of experts, Paul Volcker released the report of his Independent Panel Review into the World Bank Group Department of Institutional Integrity (INT). The review was in response to increasing criticism of the INT, through its first 8 years of operation, and recommendations in the Volcker’s report gave some level of hope to claimants who had increasingly become INT fodder.

On the 27th November, after having submitted evidentiary documents relating to a counterfeit Project Management unit stamp on the World Bank Municipal Development Project sub-credit agreement, and evidentiary documents relating to a $100 million dollar manipulation of Yerevan Water and Wastewater Company (YWSC) company finances by the Municipal Development Project’s Authorized representative, GAP's Director of International Programs wrote to the INT:

In the interests of expediency, Mr. Tasker requests that INT respond more clearly to the documentation he has already provided. Because of the complexity of the matter and the quantity of material, it also seems necessary that any review of Mr. Tasker's documentation by INT would require consultation with Mr. Tasker and a number of his witnesses in Yerevan. If such a step is acceptable to INT, we will be pleased to arrange it with Mr. Tasker.

On the 31st January, Mr. Shapiro replied and wrote:

We would like to have an opportunity to review that documentation, in order to continue our efforts into your client's allegations.

Please note that INT will not provide any information regarding its investigative methodology as a precondition to receiving information on allegations of possible fraud or corruption. What I can state is that your client's allegation will receive a full objective review on the merits.

In September 2007, Mr. Shapiro wrote to GAP and advised that the claim had been categorized ‘Medium’ priority. Fortunately the Volcker report was published soon after that message, in which Clause 43 stated: “INT periodically reviews the "medium" priority cases in the event that additional evidence develops to warrant a higher ranking, but normally these cases are not otherwise investigated”.

That effectively meant the people of Armenia were not to benefit from an INT investigation into multi-million fraud, corruption and embezzlement, even though it was exposed by a Parliamentary Commission and had been detailed and formally submitted by the Government Accountability Project to the INT in a 62 page ‘Demand Letter’

The Shapiro message goes on with - Similarly, I will tell you that going forward we will not be engaging in a continuous back and forth negotiation with your client about what evidence he provides.

One Volcker Panel Review recommendation can be found in Clause 120 of his report, which states:

“INT should furnish regular updates to complainants and victims on the general status of an investigation and promptly respond to specific queries from complainants and victims, INT should develop written guidelines to ensure that its investigators adequately communicate with complainants and victims of alleged staff misconduct.”

It is quite clear that the INT has no intention of paying attention to Volcker.

The Shapiro message then included an interesting phrase that “If your client chooses to provide this information, we will safeguard it as we would any evidence which INT receives”.

It is not clear what Shapiro means by ‘safeguard’, but if the commitment is similar to the INT commitment to safeguard confidentiality of claimants, who are foolish enough to answer the World Bank call and submit information to the INT, then I have little reason to be encouraged. On the 31st July 2004, in response to this claimant’s initial inquiry to the INT confidential hotline, the INT Integrity Officer wrote: “I will forward your request to the Task-Manager of the project in the Bank for his information and to the Country Manager”. The Country Manager is one of the persons Tasker accuses as being centrally involved in the fraud and corruption.

Of course, together with GAP, we are most willing to provide ALL the evidentiary material to the INT. But in the light of our experiences through the past 10 months, when the INT has given absolutely no indication that it has any intention whatsoever of carrying out a worthwhile investigation in response to this claim, we will be submitting evidence on a scheduled basis. And at the same time, the evidence will be published through this blog, so that the internet community will know the details of how the World Bank drives fraud and corruption in developing countries, and how the INT prefers to defend the corrupt integrity of the Bank to investigating claims of fraud and corruption.

Saturday, January 26, 2008

World Bank Armenia Corruption fallout continues

Since the beginning of October last year, the 168 Hours newspaper has been reporting on activities in Washington to persuade the World Bank’s oversight organization, the Department of Institutional integrity, to carry out a full investigation into claims of corruption in Armenian World Bank projects. The action has been led by Bruce Tasker, based on information he gathered through a study he managed for a Parliamentary Commission headed by Deputy Speaker Vahan Hovhanissian in 2004, and has been going on since January 2007, supported in Washington by the Government Accountability Project.

In June 2007 Paul Wolfowitz, the Bank’s President resigned under pressure as a result of compromising information exposed by the Government Accountability Project (GAP), and now in January 2008, Suzanne Folsom, Director of the INT has also resigned, in this case under pressure from her own colleagues. Folsom was installed by Wolfowitz instead of better qualified candidates, and it was generally known that in preference to investigating corruption in World Bank projects, she would block claims and sometimes encourage reprisals against the claimants – generally referred to as ‘Whistleblowers’.

Following her resignation, Tony Cantor, the British Ambassador in Armenia, prior to leaving Armenia into retirement, informed Tasker that the INT had eventually started the investigation which Tasker and GAP had been pressing for throughout most of 2007. Ambassador Cantor advised that INT is now working closely with Roger Robinson, the former World Bank Country Manager in Armenia, who is presently in Kyrgyzstan (together with Jimmy McHugh, his IMF partner in Armenia). The INT then wrote that it has started a review of the claim. But knowing how effectively the INT operates, it is impossible to imagine when, or if that review may become an investigation. It could possibly take a further year, or even longer. So the 168 Hours newspaper will keep its promise and report on the campaign until the INT reaches its final conclusions.

168 Hours has reported numerous aspects of the corruption, including that more than 4 million dollars of Municipal Development Project money was spent to buy water pipes to replace the worst of Yerevan’s old pipes, but the pipes were used for other profit making activities; that Yerevan’s water users paid more than 8 million dollars for water meters which the World Bank claimed were paid for by the Municipal Development Project; that the Authorized Representative of the International operator, Richard Walkling, in his dual and conflicting role as General Director of the Yerevan Water Company, falsified annual accounts, overstating the value of company assets by almost 100 million dollars, which in 2003 resulted in a loss to the Armenian people of more than 10 million dollars; and how at the start of the project, the Director of the Project Management Unit (PMU) used a counterfeit stamp on a World Bank document to gain approval of the 30 million dollar project loan. We have also reported how Mr. Varoudakis, the present World Bank Armenia Country Manager, convened a press conference and recklessly announced that the Bank considered there were no major irregularities with the project, when later at a meeting with Tasker and GAP’s International Project Director, he admitted he had not even seen the documentation.

Bruce Tasker has now provided more information to the 168 Hours newspaper, and today we can report on how in 2003, Richard Walkling, in his capacity as General Director of the Yerevan Water Company, received a 20 million dollar subsidy from the state budget (the people of Armenia) and yet was able to register a loss of more than 55 million dollars, when the company has annual expenses of about 10 million dollars.

Through the first 28 months of the Municipal Development Project, with Walkling as General Director of the Water Company, he received more than 7 million dollars in subsidies from the Armenian state budget, specifically to help the company pay for the 6 million dollars worth of electricity it used each year. But despite that assistance, in a little more than 2 years, he managed to build up an electricity debt of almost 25 million dollars. In May 2002, the Government signed a decree that 10 billion Drams worth of the electricity debt should be eliminated by converting it to capital. In October the entire water company’s electricity debt, which by then was nearly 13 billion Drams ($25 million), 10 billion of which was earmarked for conversion to capital, was transferred to the state company Haigasart, under the Government’s Integrated Finance Rehabilitation Plan. In December of the same year the water company received a subsidy of more than 3 billion Drams ($6 million) from the state budget to pay a part of its electricity debt, and in December it paid that money to Haigasart. The water company financial records for 2002 did not detail the transfer of the electricity debt to Haigasart, nor did it record the receipt and payment of 3 billion Drams. And rather than clearly detailing the electricity debt as it had done for the previous four years, it double accounted the debt by concealing it as a separate general debt item.

Then in 2003, in addition to the $7 million and the further 6 million state subsidies already received, the company received a grant of more than 10 billion Drams ($20 million), to be recorded as an increase to the company charter capital, and most of which was to be used to pay the remaining electricity debt. By that time, the total state assistance had reached nearly 35 million dollars.

The result was that in 2002, 10 billion Drams worth of electricity debt was eliminated by converting it to capital, then that eliminated debt, plus another 3 billion Drams worth of electricity debt that had accumulated during the year was transferred as a debt to Haigasart and then the transferred debt was double accounted by concealing it in the company financial records. Then in 2003, the state budget paid more than 10 billion Drams in cash to increase the company charter capital, which had already been increased through conversion of the electricity debt.

This created a potential loss to the state budget of more than 30 billion Drams ($55+ million), through cash payments made by the state budget to the water company; as a result of the water company converting electricity debt of more than 10 billion Drams; and then through concealing transfer of the same electricity debt to Haigasart and registering it as a general debt.

To add to that, in preparation for the Municipal Development Project, in 1999 the state provided more than 5 billion Drams to the company in a plan to consolidate under a single credit agreement all the 9.5 billion Drams worth of electricity debts it had accumulated through years 1996 to 1999. But the 5 billion Drams worth of electricity debt was not eliminated from the company accounts, as it should have been. In 2003, agreement was reached between the company and the state that a part of that 9.5 billion Dram credit should also be converted to capital and the remainder should be written off. That operation was manipulated to cost the company another several billion Drams.

Then, on top of creating a loss of more than 30 billion Drams through manipulating electricity debts, the water company wrote off customer debts worth more than 14 billion Drams, which was a further loss to the state budget. Moreover, after the embezzlement scam, purportedly to increase the water company charter capital, the charter capital was not in fact increased as it should have been.

So, in 2003 the Yerevan water company, under management of Richard Walkling, who was also Authorized Representative of the Italian company A. Utilities, managing the World Bank financed Municipal Development Project, was at the center of embezzlement which cost the people of Armenia more than 55 million dollars.

The correct way for Walkling to have rehabilitated the water company’s finances would have been to simply write off the 13 billion Dram electricity debt (‘Payables’) and to write off 13 billion Drams worth of customer debt (‘Receivables’). In this way the two debt write-offs would have balanced each other out and the operation would have created a zero loss for the company. And although the state budget would have suffered a loss of 13 billion Drams, that would have been much less than the massive losses created, and the Armenian people would not have needed to pay 10 billion Drams in cash to the water company.

In 2004, which should have been Walkling’s last year in charge of the project (and the water company), after all that manipulative rehabilitation of company finances, he managed to accumulate yet another loss of about 40 million dollars.

These are some of a number of reasons why Bruce Tasker and the Government Accountability Project are demanding that the Department of Institutional Integrity in Washington carries out a full investigation into the fraud, corruption and embezzlement, perpetrated by Richard Walkling and overseen by the World Bank’s Roger Robinson, as a result of the Bank’s Municipal Development Project.