World Bank retaliates against Parliamentary Whistleblower

World Bank retaliates against Parliamentary Whistleblower
Showing posts with label Corruption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Corruption. Show all posts

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Blowing the World Bank Whistle

Blowing the World Bank Whistle is an ongoing effort which started in 2004 with a Parliamentary Commission study into a World Bank financed project in the Republic of Armenia, and it continues on to an effort to persuade the Bank’s watchdog organisation, the Department of Institutional Integrity (INT), to instigate a full investigation into the wide-ranging and high-level fraud, corruption and embezzlement, exposed by the study.

In 2004, the Commission reported the fraud, corruption and embezzlement to the World Bank Armenia Country Manager and to the Department of Institutional Integrity, but by the end of 2006, rather than the problems being resolved, the individual who managed the study found that he had become the subject of World Bank ‘Whistleblower’ reprisals.

The whistleblower then found that the Bank's own Department of Institutional Integrity often prefers to punish whistleblowers rather than to solve the problems within the Bank and despite ever-increasing commitments by the major international institutions to clamp down on corruption, it is virtually impossible to find an organisation to support a claim against the Bank.

But Washington’s most influential human rights and freedom of speech organisation, the Government Accountability Project (GAP), after carefully studying the study documents, submitted a 'Demand Letter' to the INT, in support of a claim by the Whistleblower against the Bank. Later, the British Government, which had been informed of the problems since the time of the study in 2004, formally added its support.

On the 6th September, GAP released a report of its study into the INT and highlighted four claims of corruption in World Bank projects. This claim was one of those projects, and because of the wide-ranging nature of the corruption, plus the comprehensive and compelling evidence, GAP singled it out with a special request to the INT to conduct a full investigation. Armenia’s Municipal Development Project is now featured on GAP’s website.

Just prior to the GAP report, Mr. Shapiro of the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity eventually responded to the letters from GAP, explaining that the INT has three categories for claims, ‘High’, ‘Medium’ and ‘Low’, and Armenia is ‘Medium’. Mr. Shapiro however declined to commit to when a full investigation will be carried out.

This claim has also been officially registered with the Volcker Panel, which has been studying INT operations and which released its report on the 13th September. The report does not feature any specific projects, because although according to the Volcker report, the “INT plays an important role in the Bank’s overall good governance and anti-corruption drive”, the “Purpose and Scope” of the Volcker Panel study was to “carry out a comprehensive review of the INT to assess how it can best contribute to the Bank’s poverty reduction mission and to safeguard the institution from legal, fiduciary and other risks”.

It is clear from the Purpose and Scope of the Volcker Panel study that the Bank is more concerned about its own security than about protecting the interests of those who would like a reduction in the level of corruption in World Bank projects, those generally referred to as ‘Whistleblowers’.

Prior to reading the Volcker Panel study report, it was assumed that the Armenian claim was near the bottom of the INT list for investigation, because according to INT procedures, low category claims are simply filed and receive no further attention. But the Volcker study has found that “Generally, INT has been able to investigate only high priority cases” and normally medium priority cases are NOT investigated.

So although an Armenian Parliamentary Commission has submitted comprehensive and compelling evidence to the World Bank, claiming tens of millions of dollars worth of corruption, according to Volcker, the Armenian people should not expect an INT inquiry.

In July the UK Foreign & Commonwealth Office established an ‘International Development Committee’, which invites organizations and individuals to “submit 'evidence' to ensure that assistance delivered through the World Bank is in line with the priorities and objectives of the Department for International Development (DFID)”. Details of this claim are being prepared as the basis for ‘evidence’ for the committee and that will include how the UK representation at the World Bank in Washington continually ignores letters from the British Ambassador in Armenia, in which he requests their support and information about the status of the claim.

The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund will be meeting in Washington at the end of October to present requests for continued finance to the U.S. Congress. GAP will be working with Congress to make sure it is aware of how inadequately the INT responds to claims of World Bank corruption. That will be followed by work with the U.S. Senate, which has just unanimously voted to investigate World Bank corruption.

Whilst the INT is deciding on how and when it may be able to respond to the 'Demand Letter' it received from GAP in March this year, Armenian corruption is being subjected to high-level exposure in Washington and in London; corrupt World Bank consultants continue with their corruption in Armenia; the World Bank Armenia country manager is free to orchestrate more corruption (now in Kyrgyzstan), and nine months after his departure from Armenia, the World Bank's Armenia office still awaits the arrival of its replacement country manager.

This blog covers the process from the beginning; it details the fraud and corruption, the Bank’s reprisals to the whistleblower, and continues with the ongoing action to persuade the Department of Institutional Integrity to initiate a full investigation into the matter.

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist

Armenian Parliamentary Commission (2004)


Sunday, February 8, 2009

Stealing Armenia – How he did it!

Since the turn of the century the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund have been driving a rampantly corrupt agenda in the Republic of Armenia. This was exposed in 2004 by an Armenian Parliamentary Commission, which found that several tens of millions of dollars worth of World Bank credits were being misappropriated and the IMF was failing in its duty to stop the theft of valuable state assets.

By March 2007, the Bank and the IMF had made no effort to resolve the problems, so Americas leading human rights and freedom of speech organization, the Government Accountability Project (GAP), submitted the details to the Bank’s watchdog body, the Department of Institutional Integrity (INT), and GAP has since been pressing for a full investigation. Throughout 2007, the INT ignored repeated requests to investigate the problems, so in February 2008 GAP submitted a petition to Robert Zoellick, World Bank President, asking for his support. By the end of May, the INT was still not cooperating, so GAP submitted a full report to members of the U.S. Congress, who are now looking into the matter.

Today, Khosq provides the opportunity to bring this information to the attention of a new Armenian internet community.

In 2004, Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission found corruption estimated to be in the region of two hundred million dollars, a massive amount for Armenia which at the time had a state budget of about four hundred million. The problems were associated with the World Bank’s Municipal Development Project, designed to improve Yerevan’s water utility, and the ‘Government’s Integrated Finance Rehabilitation Plan’, a devious mechanism to eliminate hundreds of millions of dollars worth of old electricity debts, supported by the Bank and under IMF ‘Surveillance’.

The Commission concluded that the Bank and the IMF were clearly in cahoots with the Armenian authorities, depriving Armenia’s under-privileged of tens of millions of poverty reduction dollars and using them for state-backed profit-making activities, and illicitly transferring hundreds of millions of dollars worth of state assets to corrupt state cronies and their partners-in-crime.

Roger Robinson, the World Bank Country Manager at the time, initially reacted to the accusations with anger, but he later backed down and paid lip service to the claims. The IMF’s Permanent Representative in Armenia however had a more philosophical view of the affair. When asked: Should he not be stopping a One Hundred Million Dollar scam, as he was meant to do in accordance with his IMF technical assistance agreement? He replied ‘That depends”. When asked: On what does it depend? – He answered – “My Conscience”.

It turned out that Jimmy McHugh’s conscience was not all it could have been and a worthless document, which the Armenian authorities had valued at $107 million was used to privatize Armenia’s Kajaran molybdenum factory.

Jimmy McHugh was later asked to comment on why the $100 million Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro-Power Cascade was transferred to ‘Russian Companies’ at a reduced value of $25 million in 2002, and then in 2003 the newly privatized Russian owned Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro-Power Cascade received a 15 Billion Dram ($30 million) donation from the state budget. He declined to answer that question.

These two scams totalling about $140 million were used to ‘privatize’ two of Armenia’s most valuable state assets, which had a total book value of more than $200 million. Today, more than a billion dollars would be needed to build the five hydro-power stations which make up the 400+ megawatt Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro-Power Cascade, including the man-made reservoirs, kilometres of water channels, and all the electricity generating, transformation and distribution systems! But the entire system was transferred to Russian companies at virtually no charge, in the same way as the molybdenum factory was transferred to a German company – at virtually no charge!

How many other of the billions of dollars worth of state assets must have been ‘Privatized’ in this criminal way?

Vahan Hovhanissian promised to report the details to the people of Armenia in 2004, together with another $60 million dollars worth of corruption and embezzlement his Commission found in the World Bank financed Municipal Development Project, which accordingly failed to bring the significant improvements to the Yerevan water system the Bank had promised. But he chose the more attractive option of keeping the information to himself. Then in October 2007, Prime Minister Serge Sargsyan said he was ready to re-look at the matter, but that also turned out to be empty words.

The UK’s Serious Fraud Office continues to monitor the INT response to GAP’s request for an investigation, the Armenian opposition press has covered the campaign in a string of articles, the Armenia chapter of Transparency International has added its support, the Institute for Democracy and Human Rights (IDHR) has published an article on this scandal in its quarterly journal, and today readers of khosq can see the details for themselves by applying to the writer of this article for copies of documents.

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist

Armenian Parliamentary Commission (2003/4)

Friday, February 6, 2009

More Armenian Foreign Direct Investment Games

According to Nikolay Pavlov, Russia’s Ambassador, and Alexander Zaytsev, trade commissioner to Armenia, Russia will be extending a $500 million dollar loan to the people of Armenia, to support Russia’s existing Armenia projects; specifically construction of a new power-generating unit and modernization of the railways.


The new power-generating unit could possibly be the multi-billion dollar nuclear power station that Armen Moffsissian has promised, an absolute must during this crisis period. Or it could be the 5th block of the Hrazdan gas fired power-generating unit, which has soaked up the best part of a billion dollars through its ten or more years of construction, but recently transferred to HyRusGasArt on the promise that Russia would invest a further two hundred million dollars to finally bring it into operation. Or maybe it could be Yerevan’s new gas-fired power-generating unit, for which Japan provided a $140 million credit in 1999, the construction of which started in 2005, and although Moffsissian has been uncommonly silent about that major project, no doubt now close to completion. Or it could be one of the Araks hydro-power plants, or a host of other impressive Armen Moffsissian energy projects.


Modernization of the railways does not however present so much of a quandary; Armenia’s entire system was handed over to Russia a year ago, on the understanding that Russia would invest $570 million. According to the Armenian media, to date the investment has amounted to a 1.8 million dollar repair of an electric locomotive in Georgia, the purchase of modern apartments, the import of numerous ‘Jeeps’, and enormous salaries for the company executives who will soon be occupying the new Russian rail administration offices at the head of Kocharian’s Northern Prospect. Gurgen Sargsyan, Armenia’s recently appointed Minister of Transport, and an exceptionally level-headed official amongst an otherwise impressive gang of regime bandits, recently said.... “Not everything, that is invested, may be considered investments". Armenia now knows the truth of those words.

As has happened so many times before in Armenia that which on the surface appears to be healthy foreign direct investment, in practice turns out to be a regime-backed financial scam. In the same way as the 5th block of the Hrazdan gas fired power-generating unit has for the past ten years served as a multi-hundred-million-dollar money spinner for the regime, so now is the Armenian railway system. In this instance a $500 million Russian credit is being imposed on the people of Armenia, to pay for investments promised by one of the various Russian companies which have methodically taken over the vast majority of Armenia’s billions of dollars worth of state assets.

Armenia’s state propaganda machine prefers to explain that this $500 million is for funding small and medium business development projects - a sum somewhat larger than the five or ten million dollars the regime normally manages to find to titillate the Armenian fancy. But in practice Russian investors are again being allowed to get away with this highly corrupt, fraudulent and illegal multi-billion dollar activity. Why, because within the ranks of those Russian foreign investors will be found a dominant representation of Armenia’s bandit regime.


So whilst Armenia plunges ever-deeper into the crisis which the regime has long been preparing, with enthusiastic support from the World Bank and the IMF, Kocharian and Sargsyan will continue to divert massive funds to their personal indulgence – funds that rightfully belong to the people.

Saturday, January 3, 2009

Armenia – A World Bank New Year Message

Congratulations for successfully completing the year 2008, despite the recent adverse developments in the global economy the economy grew by 8.7% in real terms in the Financial Year 2007/08, slightly lower than the estimate reported in June by 0.2% of GDP, following further validation of economic data by the Bureau of Statistics. This excellent economic performance was because of continued growth in the industry and services sectors.

The regional and adverse global developments in calendar year 2008 have tested the strength of the economy. Once again it has been proved that the economic management policy framework put in place by the Government is sound. The economy quickly and fully recovered from the temporary disruption of trade flows last year, on account of the political upheavals.

The Government knew that the only way forward was to rehabilitate the economy and increase production, so the economy was completely liberalised to eliminate bureaucratic red tape that constrained economic activity. Production increased and the shortages of the 1990s were eliminated and since there has been a situation of plenty where the producers have the right incentives to produce. The temporary disruption of flow of trade caused shortages of fuel and other merchandise during 2008, and that led to increased transport costs and a rise in prices of consumer goods. Although normal trade flow was quickly restored and has since stabilised, the prices of consumer goods and inputs used in manufacturing have remained high. This is due to the rising prices in the economies of trading partners and the effect of high oil prices on the international market earlier on in the year.

There is awareness that the on-going global financial crisis has spread in other countries. This has sparked off an economic slowdown in the world economy. This global crisis may somehow affect the economy, given that it is small and peripherally integrated in the wider global economy. That could be through reduced demand for exports, a decline in remittances from those working abroad and sending money home, reduced private foreign direct investments and other financial flows. However, as historical performance has proven, the economy is resilient. Therefore, there should not be concern that the economy will be badly hurt. The economy remains strong and the Government’s economic policy framework is sound.

The banking sector is sound, stable and solvent, mainly due to adequate regulation and vigorous supervision that has minimized risky credit behavior. It is also because banks are well-capitalized and did not have exposures to the sub-prime mortgages that sparked off the global financial crisis.

Therefore, the banking sector is not exposed to the toxic debt that has caused havoc in the American and European financial markets. Domestic banks were not involved in the sub-prime because they have large reserves that have made the financial sector abundantly solvent. On account of this reason, banks had no reason to borrow externally to finance domestic lending and to meet their operational costs. This is not by accident. It is a consequence of the good economic policies of the Government which have created a supportive business environment that has allowed private banks and other businesses to make profit despite the stiff competition.

Investors should therefore be assured that the impact of the spillover effects of the global financial crisis on the financial sector will be minimal, contrary to those pessimists who profess doom.

The economic outlook remains robust, with real economic growth for the financial year 2008/09 estimated in the range of 7% to 7.5% per annum. While this target may seem ambitious given the global financial crisis, it is lower than what achieved in recent years and is in line with average growth rates in the previous five years. The economic growth target of 7% - 7.5% is also based on the strong and sound policy framework that the Government has worked hard to put in place over the last decade. This has led to a diversified economy that is better cushioned against shocks. As an example, as a result of export diversification, export destinations have also been diversified, with a large proportion going to the regional markets.

The restoration of peace and security and the on-going efforts for the economic recovery of the region gives optimism for a brighter economic future in the year ahead. The outlook for the economy is favorable and the country’s economic fundamentals remain strong. The Government beginning in Financial Year 2008/09 has allocated resources for the development and improvement of major trade routes along the Northern corridor. The preparatory work will start in 2009 and the designs for the road projects are going to be completed during the FY 2009/10 to enable future construction works to commence. On the Western route, services will soon be restored, as these transport routes are critical for regional integration and inter-regional trade.

Previously large investment outlays were being provided by donors; but now the Government has demonstrated that it can take full charge of its investment projects/programs. As far as our development partners are concerned, they should feel happy that the Republic is now graduating from dependency on aid.

In the energy sector, the Government, with its own resources, has kick-started the commencement of the 250 Megawatt Hydro-power Project even while private financiers were yet to conclude their financing arrangements. The Hydro-power Project construction is progressing on schedule and will be complete in the estimated time-frame by January 2011. The Government has also decided to commence construction of a larger-sized Hydro-power Project which will create generation capacity of 700 Megawatts. While commencement of this project may occur slightly later than earlier planned owing to further geo-technical and environmental studies, the site will generate over three times the amount of electricity originally envisaged. The Government is committed to also financing this project from resources generated from revenues in the Energy Fund; and will amount to about US$ 200 million by the end of this Financial Year. The Minister of Finance has been directed to ensure that more resources are budgeted so that we have sufficient resources to complete this dam.

The next stage of development in the energy sector that the Government will implement will be the development of the necessary regional and national transmission and distribution systems, including nationwide rural electrification in order to utilize the increased electricity generation. This will also entail development of Regional-wide transmission infrastructure to export power to our neighbors.

The strategic interventions outlined are therefore meant to ensure that the there are no shortages in infrastructure provision that will constrain the growth of the economy in the near future. The implementation of these critical infrastructure developments will enable take-off into a modern and transformed social and economic nation state with guaranteed prosperity for future generations to come.

In the Industry sector, the construction boom that started a few years ago is set to continue in the coming year; and investment in production of cement has increased substantially. Following a revision in the method of calculation of FDI and remittances, FDI increased to $946m in 2007/08, from $695 in 2006/07 and remittances amounted to $476m in 2007/08 compared to $430m in 2006/07.

In the services sector, tourism continues to do well, as arrivals at the airport which are an indicator of tourist visits, increased from 360, 000 arrivals in 2006/07 to 440,000 in Financial Year 2007/08. The boom in the tourism sector is also reflected in the increasing number of hotels, restaurants and other related facilities. Also, there has been a fast growth in the demand for mobile phones because there had been a chronic suppressed need for communication.

While growth in the agricultural sector is lower than in other sectors, the Government is dealing decisively with the matter, including the addition of value to agricultural production and increasing access to markets to achieve the overall objective of increasing household incomes. The Government has restructured a program to ensure focus on provision of researched varieties of plants and better breeds of livestock to farmer groups organized into model, nucleus, lead and other farmers. All categories of farmers must be reached by the program.

These measures will go along way towards resolving the weaknesses in the agriculture sector that make it lag behind the rest of the economy in terms of growth. Together with the infrastructure developments outlined, market access of increased agricultural production will be assured and, consequently, incomes of households will be increased.

The Ministers of Agriculture and of Finance, and all stakeholders in the agricultural sector, should intervene to support increased production forthwith. Savings and Credit Cooperatives (SACCOs) are needed to build the necessary capacity to manage savings and micro-finance that may come from other sources. The Government will provide micro-finance is to increase agricultural production.

There have been calls by some individuals, including Members of Parliament, for the Government to control the prices of some commodities, particularly food and fuel, in response to the high prices. The concerns are shared; but action must be orderly and not in a panicky way; otherwise confusion may be caused which may not be good for business.

Empathies go out to all who have had problems of one kind or another; especially those who have lost their loved ones.

........................End of Message.

This World Bank New Year Message could apply admirably to Armenia, or possibly to Azerbaijan, or even Georgia. But it is in fact excerpts taken from Uganda’s President Yoweri Museveni State of the Nation Address on New Year’s Day, in which he assured a better 2009.

President Yoweri Museveni has been the President of Uganda since 1986, responsible for:

1. Crimes Against Humanity

Orchestrating Genocide in Northern Uganda, where he has incarcerated nearly two million people in concentration camps, euphemistically known as “protected villages.” Read a Report by the Govt. of Uganda, WHO, UNICEF and others (pdf version). At the height of the crisis, (circa 2005), more than 1,000 people per week were dying from preventable diseases in these Modern Day Concentration Camps. More people have died from conditions in the camps themselves than at the hands of the LRA (Lord's Resistance Army) or government forces, and over 20,000 children have been abducted.

2. Crimes Against Humanity II

In 2005, Museveni’s government was found guilty by the International Court of Justice for committing grave war crimes in the DRC, including: the invasion and plundering of the natural resources of the Democratic Republic of the Congo and of fomenting ethnic cleansing. Uganda was ordered to pay the DRC $6-$10 billion.

3. Rampant Corruption

Under Museveni, Uganda is one of the most corrupt countries in the world. Yet, donor countries including the US, keep donating money to the regime without holding Museveni accountable for corruption.

4. Lawlessness I

President Museveni has no respect for international laws. He came to power using child soldiers and continues to coerce children into joining his armed forces to sustain his regime (See China Keitetsi’s story).

5. Lawlessness II

Locally, President Museveni does not respect the rule of law: he used soldiers to invade the nation’s High Court twice to intimidate judges, has exhibited complete disrespect for human rights, and bribed Ugandan Parliamentarians to amend the constitution to remove presidential term limits. The removal of term limits places Museveni as a de facto life president. Museveni has also been involved in land grabbing without the consent of the owners.

What future for Armenia, whilst the World Bank continues its politically motivated and highly corrupt agenda?

Thursday, November 27, 2008

Letter to Senator Leahy

Government Accountability Project

National Office

1612 K Street, NW Suite #1100 • Washington, D.C. 20006

202.408.0034 • www.whistleblower.org

November 18, 2008

The Honorable Patrick J. Leahy

Chairman, State, Foreign Operations, and Related Programs

Subcommittee on Appropriations

127 Dirksen Senate Office Building

Washington DC 20510

Dear Senator Leahy,

We, the organizations and individuals undersigned, write to urge you to hold the World Bank accountable for its failure to comply with the legislated requirements for transparency attached to the contributions of the United States.

According to Sec. 668 (c)(1)(D) and (E) of the 2008 Consolidated Appropriations Act, which became Public Law 110-161 on December 26, 2007, “Ten percent of the funds appropriated by this Act under the heading ‘International Development Association’ shall be withheld from disbursement until the Secretary of the Treasury reports to the Committees on Appropriations that… (D) the World Bank has made publicly available the reports of the Department of Institutional Integrity, and any subsequent review of corrective actions for such reports, including, but not limited to … the May 2006 report on Credit Number 3703 DRC, Grant number H193 DRC, and Grant number H010 DRC; and (E) the World Bank is implementing the recommendations of the ‘Volcker Panel’ report in a timely manner.”

To date, the Bank has not publicly released the May, 2006 Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) report on the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). On April 28, 2008, the World Bank released an INT report entitled “Democratic Republic of Congo: Emergency Demobilization and Reintegration Project: Redacted Report”. This undated report – which mentions events that occurred in 2007 – is not the May 2006 report(s) specifically called for in the legislative provision.

Further, the Bank has not responded to Sec. 668 (c)(1)(E), as it has failed to implement recommendation made by the Volcker Panel, which was commissioned to review the practices of INT. In November 2007, the Bank approved the Panel’s recommendations. Among other lapses, however, INT has not complied with the following fundamental recommendation of the Volcker Panel:

Ø Rights of Complainant to Notice of Case Status: The Volcker Panel recommended that “INT should furnish regular updates to complainants and victims on the general status of an investigation and promptly respond to specific queries from complainants and victims.” But when a complainant requested information on the status of his allegations, INT refused to provide this information. Instead, an INT official told the Government Accountability Project, which advises the complainant, that “INT will not provide any information regarding its investigative methodology” and “going forward we will not be engaging in a continuous back and forth negotiation with your client...” The “regular updates to complainants” that the Volcker Panel recommended became, in the parlance of INT, “a continuous back and forth negotiation” that would be eschewed by the department.[1]

Finally, the Bank has failed to respond to Sec. 1505 (a)(11) of the 2006 Foreign Operations, Export Financing and Related Programs Appropriations Act, which became Public Law 109-102 on November 14, 2005. This Act states that it is the policy of the United States that each multilateral development bank “implement best practices in domestic laws and international conventions against corruption for whistleblower and witness disclosures and protections against retaliation for internal and lawful public disclosures by the bank’s employees and others affected by such bank’s operations who challenge illegality or other misconduct that could threaten the bank’s mission, including: (1) best practices for legal burdens of proof; (2) access to independent adjudicative bodies, including external arbitration based on consensus selection and shared costs; and (3) results that eliminate the effects of proven retaliation.” The Bank’s new whistleblower protection policy, which was approved in June 2008, does not meet the last two standards, as it does not offer the right to external arbitration and does not recognize the right to meaningful relief for vindicated whistleblowers.

Without access to external arbitration when protesting retaliatory dismissal, discrimination or demotion, whistleblowers confront a judicial forum in which the Bank is both the defendant and the judge. Experts on judicial proceedings at intergovernmental organizations have recommended independent, external arbitration as a responsible way to resolve this conflict. To comply with the requirements in U.S. law, the Bank must commit to guaranteeing external arbitration as part of its pending conflict resolution system reforms. To date, there is no indication from the Bank that this measure will be adopted.

The Bank’s new staff rule providing whistleblower protection fails to “eliminate the effects of proven retaliation,” as it does not provide for mandatory reinstatement for whistleblowers who prevail. Under the new policy, Bank management retains the right to argue for the dismissal of the whistleblower if it deems that such an action is “in the best interests of the institution.” The party found culpable of misconduct must not retain the right to influence a decision on the remedy available to the whistleblower. A preliminary review of Administrative Tribunal cases, the ultimate judicial forum for staff members, has found that of the complainants who challenged termination successfully on due process or substantive grounds between 2000 and March 30, 2008, less than 15 percent of cases concluded with actual re-instatement. In the remaining 85 percent of cases, plaintiffs were dismissed from institutional employment despite prevailing. Such a dismissal is particularly draconian at the World Bank, as loss of employment often means the “victorious” whistleblower must leave the country.

United States IDA appropriations to the World Bank are contingent upon compliance with these legislated standards and provisions. We urge you to ensure that these accountability measures are fully respected before further IDA disbursements are made.


Thank you for your continued leadership on these transparency and good governance issues at the international financial institutions.

Sincerely,

The Government Accountability Project

Food and Water Watch

International Rivers Network

New Rules

Friends of the Congo

Greenpeace

ActionAid



[1] These Volcker Panel violations are further detailed in the “Plundering the Yerevan Water Utility” report, which is available at http://www.whistleblower.org/doc/2008/PlunderingtheYerevanWaterUtility8.1.08.pdf .

Friday, August 29, 2008

Blowing the World Bank Whistle - Investigation Report

After 18 months of unrelenting pressure on the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) and the UK’s Serious Fraud Office (SFO), they have eventually completed their investigations into the ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ claim of multiple acts of fraud, corruption and embezzlement associated with the World Bank funded Municipal Development Project in Armenia, as exposed (but covered up) by Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission in 2004.

Washington’s Government Accountability Project (GAP), legal counsel throughout the process, submitted the 62-page claim to the INT in March 2007 and has subsequently provided the INT with several packets of compelling evidentiary documentation. GAP has persistently pressured the INT into carrying out the investigation it would otherwise have avoided, and there has been additional pressure from numerous high-ranking British Government officials in the UK, in Armenia and in Washington, who have written to and spoken to the INT on numerous occasions. Extensive human and logistical resources have been expended in the internationally-backed effort to persuade the INT and the SFO to investigate this claim, at a cost of hundreds of thousands of Dollars.

In March 2008, a team of INT investigators travelled to Armenia to interview witnesses and gather information. The work continued in Washington and on the 21st August, the British Ambassador in Armenia advised that the investigation had been completed.

The process was extensive, and investigations found that Mr. Richard Walkling, Authorized Representative for the International Operator in Armenia, ACEA – A. Utilities, managing the Municipal Development Project, was centrally involved in multiple cases of fraud, corruption and the embezzlement of Armenian public funds, in collusion with Mr. Roger Robinson, who was World Bank Armenia Country Manager at the time of the wrongdoings. The total loss to the people of Armenia, who should have benefitted from the $35 million World Bank project, was tens of millions of dollars.

Information has not been released on what corrective action the Bank may take, if any. But Roger Robinson continues to work for the Bank in Kyrgyzstan, despite having colluded in this affair, and it is understood that Richard Walkling now works as consultant in a Yerevan water project, although not financed by the World Bank. However, the recently released World Bank ‘Economic Monitoring Note’ for 2008 indicates that the Bank may now be operating more responsibly in Armenia, under the management of Mr. Aristomene Varoudakis, which is an encouraging sign that this arduous campaign could have been in some way beneficial.

The full report is being translated to Armenian, for distribution and publication, and it will be available to readers of this article upon request.

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist
Armenian Parliamentary Commission (2003/4)
Blowing the World Bank Whistle

Friday, August 15, 2008

The UK's Serious Fraud Office - A Dissapointment for the People of Armenia

Over the course of the past year, the Government Accountability Project has backed the 'Blowing the World Bank Whistle' claim of corruption in World Bank-funded projects in Armenia. A number of British nationals were at the centre of the sordid affair, so since July 2007 the UK’s Serious Fraud Office (SFO) has been monitoring the case, in accordance with the new UK ‘Bribery and Corruption Law’, which gives UK courts jurisdiction over crimes of bribery committed wholly overseas by UK nationals.

In February 2008, a senior SFO officer travelled to Washington to discuss the matter with the Department of Institutional integrity (INT), and promised to report on the trip after his return to the UK.

On the 14th August, after many requests to the SFO, and after pressure from the British Ambassador in Armenia, the SFO eventually submitted the report promised on its year-long investigations, a one page letter which included the following statement: “I have explored your allegation that one named UK citizen received what would amount to a bribe. I have spoken to the INT department of the World Bank. They have uncovered no evidence to support your allegation during their extensive enquiries”.

It was later determined that the SFO statement referred only to the matter of bribery, not to the other 10 items of fraud, corruption and embezzlement. The conclusion reached by the INT on this matter, however again brings into question its sincerity with this investigation, after more than a year, which led to this amazing decision.

The UK Government “Law on Bribery and Corruption” clearly defines bribery as “the receiving or offering/giving of any benefit (in cash or in kind) by or to any public servant or office holder or to a director or employee of a private company in order to induce that person to give improper assistance in breach of their duty to the government or company which has employed or appointed them”. This definition of bribery is in line with the UN Convention against Corruption, to which the UK is a signatory.

The INT and the SFO reached the conclusion that Richard Walkling was not offered and did not accept a bribe when he was appointed General Director of the Yerevan Water & Wastewater Company, the company to which he was contracted to manage the World Bank Municipal Development Project. However, throughout the five-year duration of the project, Walkling presented himself to the Armenian public as the Authorized Representative for the Italian water utility company A. Utilities and concealed that he was also General Director of the Armenian state water company. In practice Walkling was contracted to himself, signing his own pay checks and involved in fraud, corruption and embezzlement which cost the Armenian people tens of millions of dollars. On the one side of his contract he was protected by a corrupt Armenian government and on the other by a corrupt World Bank Country Manager - a very beneficial position.

As a result of the INT decision, the UK’s Serious Fraud Office is not able to pursue an action against Richard Walkling, because according to the UK “Law on Bribery and Corruption”, without bribery there can not be corruption – interesting?

Apparently the INT investigation is still ongoing, but in the light of this unbelievable decision on the matter of bribery, there is not much hope that the investigation will find wrongdoings with the other ten items. The action is published on the Government Accountability Project website, "The Fight in Washington against Corruption in Armenia", which has links to the basic evidentiary documents behind the claim. There are eleven exhibits, of which Exhibit 1 gives details of Richard Walkling’s ‘Conflict of Interests’, which came about as a result of him accepting a bribe offered to him by the Armenian Government.

Together with GAP, we are still pressing for a final INT report on their investigation, but in the meantime, GAP is working to have the matter brought before the U.S. Congress.

Saturday, May 17, 2008

ODA Loan to the Republic of Armenia

Supporting Construction of Electricity Transmission and Distribution Network

OECF (The Overseas Economic Corporation Fund, Japan: President, Chairman of the Board: Mr. Kyosuke Shinozawa) has decided to provide a loan of up to 5,399 million yen ($45 million) to fund "Electricity Transmission and Distribution Project" in the Republic of Armenia, and signed the loan agreement on February 18, 1999.

The loan agreement was signed at OECF head office in Tokyo by Mr. Shinozawa, President, Chairman of the Board, OECF and H.E. Mr. Merujan Michaellian, Minister of Energy.

Objectives and Outline of the Project

By constructing a power transmission and distribution network covering the entire national territory of Armenia (upgrading of substations and load-dispatching offices, improvement of communication equipment and rehabilitation of transmission and distribution network) as well as the installation of consumption meters, this project will improve the stability and reliability of power supply. Moreover, by aiming to reduce power transmission losses and increase the power charges collection rate, the project aims to strengthen the management foundation of the power transmission and distribution companies and improve Armenia's balance of international payments by more efficient use of energy resources.

The proceeds of the loan will be used for civil works, procurement of required electricity transmission equipment and consulting services (construction supervision, etc.).

This is a co-financing project with the World Bank.

Armenia Gives a Hundred Million Dollars to Russian Companies

Since the turn of the century, President Kocharian’s administration has ‘Privatized’ most of Armenia’s billions of dollars worth of state assets, much of it transferred to Russian companies using deceitful finance mechanisms. The ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ campaign has exposed that agenda and how the World Bank, the IMF and the Armenian authorities have fabricated an economic boom and covered up the alarming increase in corruption that has led to Armenia’s present crisis.

Now Armenia’s recently self appointed President Sargsyan is donating hundreds of millions of dollars to those private Russian companies to help their owners make even greater profits – again at the expense of the Armenian people.

On the 16th May the Armenia Liberty news reported that Tigran Davtian, Armenia’s newly appointed Minister of Finance, signed an agreement under which Germany will provide Armenia with another 74 million Euros ($117 million) in fresh low-interest loans designed to improve energy and water infrastructure and financial services. Davtian explained that the bulk of the sum (64 million Euros) will be spent on upgrading Armenia’s largest hydro-electric plant and building two high-voltage power transmission lines in the country’s northern regions.

Armenia’s largest hydro-electric plant is Gurmush, one of the five Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro Cascade Power Plants (HPP’s). In 2003 the entire Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro Cascade system was valued at over one hundred million dollars but was ‘Privatized by Russian Companies’ at the giveaway price of twenty-five million dollars. In 2004, Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission studied the Privatization and found that the package included a fifteen billion Drams ($29 million) cash donation from the Armenian Government and a 15 million dollar loan from Kfw. The result was that the Armenian people paid several million dollars for the honor of having that particular state asset privatized.

Armenia’s power transmission system was privatized in 2002 by Midland Resources Holding Ltd (MRH), this time at a giveaway price of $37 million, after the Government had spent a $40 million World Bank credit to prepare for the privatization, plus a further $45 million from Japan’s Overseas Economic Corporation Fund. That state asset privatization gambit cost the Armenian people more than fifty million dollars.

MRH stems from Moscow, with offices in Canada, so it was not surprising when in December 2004 the Armenian News Network / Groong reported that the company was transferred to Russia's power grid monopoly company Unified Energy System, better known as ‘RAO UES’

Today, the people of Armenia will be pleased to hear that, after having paid tens of millions of dollars to be relieved of the burden of their strategically vital and most profitable energy sector assets, the Government has now taken on a new Kfw loan to donate to the Russian owners so that they can make more profit from their companies. And Minister Davtian has signed a sovereign guarantee on behalf of the Government, committing the people of Armenia to repaying the more than one hundred million dollar credit.

Letter to IMF

12th January 2005

International Monetary Fund

Representative Office

1 Melik-Adamyan Street

Yerevan 375010

Attn: Mr James McHugh - Resident Representative

Ref: Privatization of the "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC.

Dear Mr McHugh,

With respect to the ‘Government’s Integrated Finance Rehabilitation Plan’, which is subject to IMF surveillance, Item 32, Post Balance Sheet Events in the 2002 Armenergo statement includes:

  • "In accordance with the RA Government decree #405A, dated 29 March 2003, the liability of 40 million USD owed to Russian companies for the nuclear fuel exported to Armenia during 1995-2001 should be secured by the Company:
  • The Company undertakes the liability of ANPP CJSC at the amount of 40 million USD owed to the Russian companies, offsetting its own liabilities towards ANPP CJSC.
  • The liability of "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC at the amount of 35 million DM is transferred to the Company.
  • In return, the Company receives assets of "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC at the carrying amount of 54,400,000 KAMD as at 1 April 2003, at the equivalent to 35 million DM, determined by the realisable method.
  • The Company disposes of the assets from "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC to Russian companies, at the price of 25 million USD, regarding it as payment of ANPP liability undertaken. At the same time Russian companies undertake, under the same terms, the liability of the Company owed to the State budget on the subsidiary loan provided in the framework of the project implemented by KFW."

Mr. McHugh, the sudden increase in Payables to "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC, to 17,242,226,000 Drams in 2003, from 1,720,864,000 Drams in 2002, is of interest, especially as the Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC has been transferred to Russian companies, and supplies only approximately 2 billion Drams worth of energy to Armenergo each year.

Assets worth 54,400,000,000 Drams have effectively been transferred to Armenergo, revalued to 35 million DM, and disposed of for $25 million, a total devaluation of about 75 or 80 million dollars.

The Russian companies undertake the subsidiary loan of 7,716,850,000 Drams (about $15 million) provided in the framework of the project implemented by KFW and receives a cash incentive from the Government of more than 15 billion Drams ($29 million approx.)

In my recent E-mail messages, I have referred to a number of IMF documents, which relate to transparency and accountability of Government activities, particularly with respect to the privatization of public enterprises. I include the following from the IMF web site, which I think adequately covers the approach of the CGHA Commission study into the liquidation of Armgasard and Armenergo, the financial rehabilitation, and the associated privatisation activities.

"Serious transparency concerns can arise over the manner in which public financial institutions and non-financial public enterprises are privatized. Privatization should be conducted as openly as is consistent with sound marketing considerations. It is a basic requirement of fiscal transparency that the privatization of government assets should be open to independent audit (e.g., by a national audit body), to ensure that it is carried out in accordance with the law, that the business is properly valued, and that there is competition among bidders. Indemnities given to purchasers should also be disclosed (and included in a statement of contingent liabilities)".

I thank you again for your assistance with our study, and I look forward to receiving the requested information.

Yours Sincerely,

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist and Analyst

CGHA Commission

Sunday, April 20, 2008

A Blowing the World Bank Whistle Revelation

The first ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ annual report of 11th April 2008 was accompanied by a message in which I accused the Bank and the IMF of having colluded with the Armenian authority since the turn of the century in a highly corrupt Five Billion Dollar politically motivated agenda in preparation for the imminent resolution of the Karabakh conflict. The report was distributed to hundreds of Email recipients, including Vardan Oskanian, Armenia’s outgoing Minister of Foreign Affairs, who has been reporting on the Karabakh issue for the past ten years of his tenure.

A week after that report, the Armenian press covered an analysis by Vardan Oskanian, who commented that “for the first time ever in the history of this conflict a document that they thought has reached the maturity which can be put at the OSCE Secretariat as a clear guideline”. Oskanian then makes his revelation that International financial assistance would be made available for reconstruction and resettlement of internally displaced persons - not only in the formerly occupied territories, but in all the war-affected regions of Nagorno-Karabakh. His analysis presumably includes financial assistance (which this campaign has referred to as ‘Compensation’) for resettlement of internally displaced persons who will be obliged to leave the presently occupied surrounding territories and from Karabakh.

This is the first time an Armenian or international public official has talked with the Armenian media about the question of financial assistance for displaced persons. The Minsk Group has referred to the 7 or 8 thousand Armenian and Karabakhi civilians who live in the surrounding occupied territories as ‘occupying forces’, who will simply have to leave the territory, and the 140ish thousand who presently live in Nagorno-Karabakh will apparently live in harmony with their new Azerbaijani neighbours. Neither of course is the case; there will be tens of thousands of displaced persons, and so financial assistance must be in place to compensate their losses and to assist with their re-location.

The Minsk group and the international community prefer the philosophy of Azerbaijanis and Armenians living peacefully side-by-side under an international peacekeeping force, and so they have not made public the question of compensation for displaced persons. The Armenian authorities have been eagerly looking forward to receiving the displaced persons, but preferring to keep that lucrative multi-billion dollar part of the re-settlement equation under their monopolistic control, they have withheld information about the compensation package from the Armenian and Karabakhi people. The Azerbaijani authorities keep quiet on compensation, knowing how hard it would be to explain to their people how several billions of dollars were paid to peacefully regain sovereignty of Karabakh and the surrounding territories. Russia, who will probably act as a go-between by converting the financial assistance package to investment, will be quietly sitting back and waiting to take its cut. And the World Bank and the IMF who have been supporting this thoroughly corrupt program, will have been scheduling in a few more years of economic boom for Armenia, based on foreign investment in Armenia’s construction sector.

But could this be a sign that the times are now a changing for Armenia’s new tyrannical authority. This recently announced Vardan Oskanian analysis of international finance for displaced persons is certainly a revelation. The details of the finance package must now be fully revealed to the peoples of Armenia and of Karabakh so that they will be able to claim the compensation that is due to them. After all, these are the peoples who will suffer after Serge Sargsyan eventually signs the agreement that will lead to resolution of the long-standing Karabakh conflict. It is for these peoples that the compensation money is being paid; not so that Armenia’s corrupt inner circle can make billions more dollars at the expense of the Armenian (and now the Karabakhi) people.

Let us hope that with enough pressure we will soon see more revelations to add to this latest revelation from Vardan Oskanian.

Sunday, April 13, 2008

Armenia’s Disgrace goes to the U.S. Congress

So here we are, after a year of asking, beseeching, shouting, petitioning and screaming for a World Bank INT investigation into the corruption that has led Armenia to its recent crisis. On Thursday 17th April, the whole affair is going before a U.S. Congressional hearing, held by the U.S. Helsinki Commission, otherwise known as the Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe, or OSCE.

The hearing will focus on the ramifications of recent developments for Armenia and the United States, especially the ongoing negotiations on Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia s qualifications for assistance from the Millennium Challenge Account. Testifying before the Commission will be: Mr. Matthew Bryza, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs, Mr. Vigen Sargsian, Assistant to the President of the Republic of Armenia, and Mr. Arman Grigorian, Spokesman for Levon Ter-Petrossian, Armenia’s former President who continues to contest the recent Presidential election farce.

The Blowing the World Bank Whistle campaign has long argued that World Bank / IMF irresponsibility has led to the crisis now unfolding in Armenia. Since the turn of the century, the World’s two most prestigious sister financial institutions have been jointly nurturing a politically motivated agenda to prepare for resolution of the Karabakh conflict. The conflict of course had to be resolved; but the secretive way in which they have chosen to tackle the problem has led to a major crisis for Armenia, which in turn has led to the U.S. Congress hearing of the 17th.

Kocharian and Sargsyan have been playing down the way their Presidential election disgrace has threatened the Millennium Challenge Account, unashamedly announcing that Russia might be allowed to make up the Two Hundred and Thirty Five Million Dollar shortfall. That they could easily do by channelling a small part of the Karabakh compensation package to a Millennium Account. And although that surrogate Millennium Account will then be used to solve their own personal challenges, rather than those of Armenia’s under-privileged, they will again argue that they have served in the people’s best interests.

In monetary terms the Karabakh compensation package is likely to be some 20 times larger than the Millennium Challenge Account. Moreover, although that compensation package will be more than adequate to finance re-location for the tens of thousands who are forced to leave Karabakh and the surrounding territories, the Kocharian / Sargsyan team will inevitably find interesting ways to add to their multi-billion dollar windfall and continue squeezing every last Dram from those who will choose to move to Yerevan.

Hopefully, on the 17th the right questions will be asked for the peoples of Armenia and Karabakh. And hopefully the U.S. Congressional hearing will be able to shed some light on what has to date been a decidedly shady operation in preparation for resolution of the Karabakh conflict. And maybe with appropriate intervention following the U.S. Congressional hearing, the people of Armenia will be able to look forward to some level of normality.

Bruce Tasker
A Year Blowing the World Bank Whistle

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Taming Armenia’s World Bank Beast

In pursuance of my year-long internationally backed campaign to persuade the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) to carry out an investigation into my claim of fraud and corruption in Armenia World Bank projects, I recently sent a message to the Bank’s Country Manager suggesting that it was not too late for his friends at the INT to come to Armenia and try to restore some level of integrity in the Bank’s Armenia operations. Amazingly, this time my call did not fall on deaf ears, I received an invitation to meet with the INT team, who had apparently sneaked into Yerevan a week earlier to carry out the long-awaited investigation. I eagerly agreed, thinking that at last the INT had seen the devastation caused by the years of World Bank irresponsibility in Armenia and had decided to intervene to regulate the situation and possibly even penalize the offenders.

But my hopes were quickly dashed by an INT senior investigator, who talked about his previous communications with me and with GAP, but who I had certainly never heard of before, let alone corresponded with. And although the INT had apparently spent the past year carrying out an initial appraisal, he had far less understanding of my claim than the thousands who have followed the action through my blog and through news reports. I understood that although my claim has been a convenient excuse for an INT trip to Yerevan that is where any association between the INT and my claim ended. In true World Bank fashion, this INT team obviously had a completely different agenda for Armenia.

There is a problem; the wild beast the Bank and its sister institution the International Monetary Fund (IMF), have been creating for Armenia since the turn of the century has not only turned on its own people, killing them for peacefully demonstrating their democratic rights, it has turned on its master, calling the U.S. President a liar and criticizing his affairs in Iraq. So the mechanism which for the past ten years has been extolling the marvelous achievements of this sorry excuse for an Armenian administration now has the task of tearing it to pieces. The ‘Caucuses Tiger’ is soon to have its teeth ripped out and thorns stuck in its feet - by the very people who bottle fed it from birth and later, in the run-up to Armenia’s recent Presidential election, taught it how to stalk and kill its prey.

For years the Bank and the IMF have been building an Armenian economic boom around remarkable levels of foreign direct investment (FDI), knowing that FDI in Armenia has been nothing more than the re-assignment of stolen state assets to oversees enterprises. The same financial institutions have turned a blind eye to money laundering, preferring to praise wonderful achievements in the construction sector; the local currency has been artificially driven to ever-increasing highs to favor monopolistic importers - at the expense of ailing domestic production, but the sister institutions have reported the Dram has strengthened in response to the economic boom. And the alarming increase in corruption which has understandably accompanied this fallacious economic boom has attracted nothing more than WB/IMF lip-service.

Today, as Armenia is moving into its meticulously prepared and nigh on irreversible WB/IMF crisis, the international community has decided that it will no longer tolerate the deceit handed to it by Armenia’s tyrants. It will not be called a liar and have its international policies criticized. So it is demonstrating its displeasure by cutting off international funding. But years of feeding the beast with poverty reduction funds which were intended for the under-privileged has enabled it to generate a self-sustaining financial capability many times more than the amount of international finance the republic receives each year. So cutting off external finance is of little significance and can easily be compensated in a number of ways, most simply by a hike in food and energy prices.

So action needs to be taken and that is why the INT investigation team has eventually arrived in Armenia. They are not here to investigate rampant fraud and corruption in World Bank Armenia projects; they are here firstly to do what they do best, to repel a comprehensively documented claim of high-level and wide-ranging World Bank corruption; and secondly to manipulate a foundation on which the Bank and the IMF will be able to report a collapsing Armenian economy, in a similar way to which since the turn of the century they have been manipulating and fabricating Armenia’s dubious economic boom. In that way, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund will be able to deal a serious blow to the beast, again at the expense of the people of Armenia, who will be forced to pay the price over the counter and who will suffer increasing oppression through many coming years.

Thursday, March 6, 2008

Transparency International Armenia Letter to the World Bank Department of Institutional Integrity (INT)

4th March 2008

Development assistance, aimed to increase the sharing between the rich and the poor and to support equitable development processes, is vital to reducing poverty, promoting market economy and strengthening democratic institutions in recipient countries. Transparency International (TI) acknowledges a critical importance to ensure that development resources are used for this intended purpose and not diverted through corruption. One of the 2007 TI policy papers entitled “Poverty, Aid and Corruption” pursues policy dialogues with individual donors and multilateral institutions to jointly decrease corruption risks in delivering assistance

Bearing this in mind, Transparency International anti-corruption center in Armenia (TIAC, Armenia) requests your attention to the case related to the World Bank funded Municipal Development Project targeted at improving the water system in Yerevan, Armenia. Since summer 2007 the organization has been contacted by Mr. Bruce Tasker, a British citizen, to signal about his findings in a position of Senior Specialist for the Armenian National Assembly (NA) ad-hoc Commission established to study the efficiency of the use of loans, grants and humanitarian aid provided to Armenia, The Commission functioned in a period from September 2003 until June 2005.

According to Mr. Tasker, when in 2004 he submitted his report on the revealed fraud, corruption and embezzlement to the World Bank and the Department of Institutional Integrity (INT), he did not get support to investigate the reported case and instead became the subject of further reprisals. In March 2007, the Washington-based "Government Accountability Project" organization supported Mr. Tasker's claim against the Bank and resubmitted his case to INT. The Armenian media covered specific details and recent developments of this case throughout 2007.

The interim report of the Commission from September 2004 provided by the NA Secretariat as per TIAC, Armenia's request also refers to serious irregularities, mismanagement and poor performance in the implementation of the Project mentioned above. However, the final report published in 2005 contains neither positive, nor negative mentioning in regard with the Project, which caused certain concerns about inconsistency of the Commission investigation. After reviewing one of the claim items of Mr. Tasker's case as well as his report submitted to the NA Commission, the organization’s expert reported to the Board that there is a solid ground for a serious inquiry.

Having poverty and development as one of five global priorities of TI movement in the fight against corruption; hoping that the World Bank shares a TI’s vision of the development aid free of corruption; and considering the follow-up on this case as a strong preventive action against future harm to development processes in Armenia, TIAC, Armenia's Board calls INT to investigate the noted case.

Monday, February 18, 2008

World Bank Armenia Corruption Marches On with Transparency

For the past six months, whilst our international team of Governmental and Non-Governmental organizations has been pressing the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) to carry out an investigation into my claim of fraud and corruption in Armenian World Bank projects, I have attended a number of meetings with the local chapter of Transparency International (TI) and provided them with copies of many of the claim documents. TI has followed my action through the limited sector of the local media which is sufficiently independent to be able to follow the claim, plus through the international media, which has notably more freedom, and today TI has a pile of claim related articles in a portfolio some 3 of 4 inches thick.

TI is one of the Worlds foremost international organizations in the fight against corruption and their reports continually repeat the need to strengthen the effort, including with respect to combating corruption within the donor organizations. I was therefore pleased to recently receive a message from TI that their board of directors had convened and eventually agreed to formally support my action, adding that their Berlin office was preparing a letter for submission to the Bank.

Today, Google alerted me to an article in the Armenian publication ArmeniaNow, which articulated how Amalia Kostanyan, Armenia’s TI director, explained that “Armenia’s Anticorruption Struggle is a major challenge”. I read the article with eagerness, convinced that she would at last make reference to my ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ campaign, especially as the Armenia TI chapter no doubt has more information than both the Bank and its Department of Institutional Integrity put together.

But again I was to be disappointed; no mention of rampant World Bank corruption; no mention of how the Department of Institutional Integrity had been fending off an investigation for the past ten months; no mention of how the Bank’s recently appointed Country Manager had announced my claim was unfounded, despite him not having seen the documentation; and no mention of the high-level international support to the claim, which accuses the former Country Manager as a colluder in the wrongdoings - at a cost to the people of Armenia of tens of millions of dollars.

It is clear that, as with most other international organizations and institutions, such as the World Bank, the IMF, the United Nations, the OSCE, and many others, which bawl about the problems created by corruption and the need to wipe it out and to penalize the corrupt, Transparency International is fully committed to talking and writing about corruption, but when it comes to supporting an effort that exposes corruption and demands that it be investigated, Transparency International’s commitment is strictly LIMITED.

Thank you Transparency International for eventually agreeing to support my claim - But no thanks.

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

World Bank Armenia Corruption – The Politics

Through the past ten months, whilst the Government Accountability Project, the UK’s Foreign & Commonwealth Office, the British Ambassador in Armenia and I have been battering our heads against the World Bank’s institutional integrity brick wall, we have been debating why, since the turn of the century, the financial institutions have been orchestrating an escalation of Armenian corruption. The Permanent Representatives of both the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have been watching how billions of dollars worth of Armenian public assets has been stolen by a small circle of state cronies, who have concealed their involvement in the takeover process by working through a variety of overseas organizations. But the institutions have made little mention of the criminal activity, preferring to highlight how Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has been the spearhead of a remarkable economic boom. The institutions have also overseen numerous financial schemes, which each year have facilitated the embezzlement of hundreds of millions of dollars worth of public funds. But they have praised foreign investment in major construction projects, knowing that foreign investment has been virtually non-existent and the construction has simply been the laundering of those funds.

When in 2004, Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission raised the corruption problem with the World Bank Country Manager, he responded with aggression, and took steps to punish unwelcomed inquisitiveness. And when the same Parliamentary Commission presented documents to the Resident Representative of the IMF, indicating a scam of more than 100 million dollars, knowing Armenia has a ‘Technical Assistance’ agreement, under which the IMF is obliged to monitor and normalize all financial activity within the Armenian state system, the representative said that he had ‘Noticed the Problem’ and explained that his intervention to stop the scam was ‘Dependent on his Conscience’. It turned out that his conscience was not all it could have been; the scam went ahead, the Armenian people lost another valuable state asset, and the IMF joined its World Bank partner in the release of another glittering report on Armenia’s remarkable economic boom.

Why have the international financial institutions been so supportive of Armenia’s precarious economic boom and why have they been so nonchalant about the major problem of corruption, which has led to what today is already a well-entrenched Armenian autocracy? Could it have been for personal gain, or for collective gain, or in pursuit of a quick economic fix for Armenia, or could there be a more sinister reason? Information that has become available leading up to the February 19th Presidential election gives grounds to believe the reason is the latter, in support of a political agenda.

The corrupt Armenian authorities have been pumping hundreds of millions of their illicitly earned dollars into hundreds of thousands of square meters of accommodation space. But the ever-increasing newly constructed apartment buildings have now stood empty for several years. Moreover, in the past year or two, the quality of construction has deteriorated from the not unimpressive of five years ago, to the decidedly slip-shod of today. Even half-built apartment buildings which have stood like skeletons on the outskirts of Yerevan since the end of the Soviet period are now being rushed to completion, using all manner of unsightly construction materials. And through the past several months, property agencies have sprung up around Yerevan, owned by the same state cronies and their buddies, when apart from those within the inner circle, who may receive a new apartment (or three) in return for services rendered, there is simply no sign of the thirty or forty thousand punters needed to bring Yerevan’s newly constructed real estate to life.

But the people of Armenia should not dismay; their economic boomer babes have got a multi-billion dollar ace tucked so well up their sleeves, that after several years of preparation, ably assisted by their friends in the international financial institutions, only the very best informed have an inkling of the full house the new President is about to slap on his Republic of Armenia table.

Soon after Serge Sargsyan has terrorized himself into the Presidential Palace, all will eventually be revealed. The people of Armenia will see a sudden influx of a new generation of Yerevanites, who will not only move into the spanking new apartments, but who will take up their positions in the booming Armenian economy, and in the new administration. The multi-billion dollar money laundering of the past years will then bear its bountiful fruit, no doubt with more help from the international community, and the people of Armenia will understand why the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) in Washington should long ago have responded to my claim and open a full investigation into fraud and corruption in Armenia World Bank projects.