World Bank retaliates against Parliamentary Whistleblower

World Bank retaliates against Parliamentary Whistleblower
Showing posts with label IMF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IMF. Show all posts

Saturday, May 17, 2008

ODA Loan to the Republic of Armenia

Supporting Construction of Electricity Transmission and Distribution Network

OECF (The Overseas Economic Corporation Fund, Japan: President, Chairman of the Board: Mr. Kyosuke Shinozawa) has decided to provide a loan of up to 5,399 million yen ($45 million) to fund "Electricity Transmission and Distribution Project" in the Republic of Armenia, and signed the loan agreement on February 18, 1999.

The loan agreement was signed at OECF head office in Tokyo by Mr. Shinozawa, President, Chairman of the Board, OECF and H.E. Mr. Merujan Michaellian, Minister of Energy.

Objectives and Outline of the Project

By constructing a power transmission and distribution network covering the entire national territory of Armenia (upgrading of substations and load-dispatching offices, improvement of communication equipment and rehabilitation of transmission and distribution network) as well as the installation of consumption meters, this project will improve the stability and reliability of power supply. Moreover, by aiming to reduce power transmission losses and increase the power charges collection rate, the project aims to strengthen the management foundation of the power transmission and distribution companies and improve Armenia's balance of international payments by more efficient use of energy resources.

The proceeds of the loan will be used for civil works, procurement of required electricity transmission equipment and consulting services (construction supervision, etc.).

This is a co-financing project with the World Bank.

Armenia Gives a Hundred Million Dollars to Russian Companies

Since the turn of the century, President Kocharian’s administration has ‘Privatized’ most of Armenia’s billions of dollars worth of state assets, much of it transferred to Russian companies using deceitful finance mechanisms. The ‘Blowing the World Bank Whistle’ campaign has exposed that agenda and how the World Bank, the IMF and the Armenian authorities have fabricated an economic boom and covered up the alarming increase in corruption that has led to Armenia’s present crisis.

Now Armenia’s recently self appointed President Sargsyan is donating hundreds of millions of dollars to those private Russian companies to help their owners make even greater profits – again at the expense of the Armenian people.

On the 16th May the Armenia Liberty news reported that Tigran Davtian, Armenia’s newly appointed Minister of Finance, signed an agreement under which Germany will provide Armenia with another 74 million Euros ($117 million) in fresh low-interest loans designed to improve energy and water infrastructure and financial services. Davtian explained that the bulk of the sum (64 million Euros) will be spent on upgrading Armenia’s largest hydro-electric plant and building two high-voltage power transmission lines in the country’s northern regions.

Armenia’s largest hydro-electric plant is Gurmush, one of the five Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro Cascade Power Plants (HPP’s). In 2003 the entire Sevan – Hrazdan Hydro Cascade system was valued at over one hundred million dollars but was ‘Privatized by Russian Companies’ at the giveaway price of twenty-five million dollars. In 2004, Vahan Hovhanissian’s Parliamentary Commission studied the Privatization and found that the package included a fifteen billion Drams ($29 million) cash donation from the Armenian Government and a 15 million dollar loan from Kfw. The result was that the Armenian people paid several million dollars for the honor of having that particular state asset privatized.

Armenia’s power transmission system was privatized in 2002 by Midland Resources Holding Ltd (MRH), this time at a giveaway price of $37 million, after the Government had spent a $40 million World Bank credit to prepare for the privatization, plus a further $45 million from Japan’s Overseas Economic Corporation Fund. That state asset privatization gambit cost the Armenian people more than fifty million dollars.

MRH stems from Moscow, with offices in Canada, so it was not surprising when in December 2004 the Armenian News Network / Groong reported that the company was transferred to Russia's power grid monopoly company Unified Energy System, better known as ‘RAO UES’

Today, the people of Armenia will be pleased to hear that, after having paid tens of millions of dollars to be relieved of the burden of their strategically vital and most profitable energy sector assets, the Government has now taken on a new Kfw loan to donate to the Russian owners so that they can make more profit from their companies. And Minister Davtian has signed a sovereign guarantee on behalf of the Government, committing the people of Armenia to repaying the more than one hundred million dollar credit.

Letter to IMF

12th January 2005

International Monetary Fund

Representative Office

1 Melik-Adamyan Street

Yerevan 375010

Attn: Mr James McHugh - Resident Representative

Ref: Privatization of the "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC.

Dear Mr McHugh,

With respect to the ‘Government’s Integrated Finance Rehabilitation Plan’, which is subject to IMF surveillance, Item 32, Post Balance Sheet Events in the 2002 Armenergo statement includes:

  • "In accordance with the RA Government decree #405A, dated 29 March 2003, the liability of 40 million USD owed to Russian companies for the nuclear fuel exported to Armenia during 1995-2001 should be secured by the Company:
  • The Company undertakes the liability of ANPP CJSC at the amount of 40 million USD owed to the Russian companies, offsetting its own liabilities towards ANPP CJSC.
  • The liability of "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC at the amount of 35 million DM is transferred to the Company.
  • In return, the Company receives assets of "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC at the carrying amount of 54,400,000 KAMD as at 1 April 2003, at the equivalent to 35 million DM, determined by the realisable method.
  • The Company disposes of the assets from "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC to Russian companies, at the price of 25 million USD, regarding it as payment of ANPP liability undertaken. At the same time Russian companies undertake, under the same terms, the liability of the Company owed to the State budget on the subsidiary loan provided in the framework of the project implemented by KFW."

Mr. McHugh, the sudden increase in Payables to "Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC" CJSC, to 17,242,226,000 Drams in 2003, from 1,720,864,000 Drams in 2002, is of interest, especially as the Sevan-Hrazdan HPPC has been transferred to Russian companies, and supplies only approximately 2 billion Drams worth of energy to Armenergo each year.

Assets worth 54,400,000,000 Drams have effectively been transferred to Armenergo, revalued to 35 million DM, and disposed of for $25 million, a total devaluation of about 75 or 80 million dollars.

The Russian companies undertake the subsidiary loan of 7,716,850,000 Drams (about $15 million) provided in the framework of the project implemented by KFW and receives a cash incentive from the Government of more than 15 billion Drams ($29 million approx.)

In my recent E-mail messages, I have referred to a number of IMF documents, which relate to transparency and accountability of Government activities, particularly with respect to the privatization of public enterprises. I include the following from the IMF web site, which I think adequately covers the approach of the CGHA Commission study into the liquidation of Armgasard and Armenergo, the financial rehabilitation, and the associated privatisation activities.

"Serious transparency concerns can arise over the manner in which public financial institutions and non-financial public enterprises are privatized. Privatization should be conducted as openly as is consistent with sound marketing considerations. It is a basic requirement of fiscal transparency that the privatization of government assets should be open to independent audit (e.g., by a national audit body), to ensure that it is carried out in accordance with the law, that the business is properly valued, and that there is competition among bidders. Indemnities given to purchasers should also be disclosed (and included in a statement of contingent liabilities)".

I thank you again for your assistance with our study, and I look forward to receiving the requested information.

Yours Sincerely,

Bruce Tasker

Senior Specialist and Analyst

CGHA Commission

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Taming Armenia’s World Bank Beast

In pursuance of my year-long internationally backed campaign to persuade the World Bank’s Department of Institutional Integrity (INT) to carry out an investigation into my claim of fraud and corruption in Armenia World Bank projects, I recently sent a message to the Bank’s Country Manager suggesting that it was not too late for his friends at the INT to come to Armenia and try to restore some level of integrity in the Bank’s Armenia operations. Amazingly, this time my call did not fall on deaf ears, I received an invitation to meet with the INT team, who had apparently sneaked into Yerevan a week earlier to carry out the long-awaited investigation. I eagerly agreed, thinking that at last the INT had seen the devastation caused by the years of World Bank irresponsibility in Armenia and had decided to intervene to regulate the situation and possibly even penalize the offenders.

But my hopes were quickly dashed by an INT senior investigator, who talked about his previous communications with me and with GAP, but who I had certainly never heard of before, let alone corresponded with. And although the INT had apparently spent the past year carrying out an initial appraisal, he had far less understanding of my claim than the thousands who have followed the action through my blog and through news reports. I understood that although my claim has been a convenient excuse for an INT trip to Yerevan that is where any association between the INT and my claim ended. In true World Bank fashion, this INT team obviously had a completely different agenda for Armenia.

There is a problem; the wild beast the Bank and its sister institution the International Monetary Fund (IMF), have been creating for Armenia since the turn of the century has not only turned on its own people, killing them for peacefully demonstrating their democratic rights, it has turned on its master, calling the U.S. President a liar and criticizing his affairs in Iraq. So the mechanism which for the past ten years has been extolling the marvelous achievements of this sorry excuse for an Armenian administration now has the task of tearing it to pieces. The ‘Caucuses Tiger’ is soon to have its teeth ripped out and thorns stuck in its feet - by the very people who bottle fed it from birth and later, in the run-up to Armenia’s recent Presidential election, taught it how to stalk and kill its prey.

For years the Bank and the IMF have been building an Armenian economic boom around remarkable levels of foreign direct investment (FDI), knowing that FDI in Armenia has been nothing more than the re-assignment of stolen state assets to oversees enterprises. The same financial institutions have turned a blind eye to money laundering, preferring to praise wonderful achievements in the construction sector; the local currency has been artificially driven to ever-increasing highs to favor monopolistic importers - at the expense of ailing domestic production, but the sister institutions have reported the Dram has strengthened in response to the economic boom. And the alarming increase in corruption which has understandably accompanied this fallacious economic boom has attracted nothing more than WB/IMF lip-service.

Today, as Armenia is moving into its meticulously prepared and nigh on irreversible WB/IMF crisis, the international community has decided that it will no longer tolerate the deceit handed to it by Armenia’s tyrants. It will not be called a liar and have its international policies criticized. So it is demonstrating its displeasure by cutting off international funding. But years of feeding the beast with poverty reduction funds which were intended for the under-privileged has enabled it to generate a self-sustaining financial capability many times more than the amount of international finance the republic receives each year. So cutting off external finance is of little significance and can easily be compensated in a number of ways, most simply by a hike in food and energy prices.

So action needs to be taken and that is why the INT investigation team has eventually arrived in Armenia. They are not here to investigate rampant fraud and corruption in World Bank Armenia projects; they are here firstly to do what they do best, to repel a comprehensively documented claim of high-level and wide-ranging World Bank corruption; and secondly to manipulate a foundation on which the Bank and the IMF will be able to report a collapsing Armenian economy, in a similar way to which since the turn of the century they have been manipulating and fabricating Armenia’s dubious economic boom. In that way, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund will be able to deal a serious blow to the beast, again at the expense of the people of Armenia, who will be forced to pay the price over the counter and who will suffer increasing oppression through many coming years.